The rise and fall of mentoring in youth justice

Article


Porteous, D. 2007. The rise and fall of mentoring in youth justice. Prison Service Journal. 170, pp. 20-24.
TypeArticle
TitleThe rise and fall of mentoring in youth justice
AuthorsPorteous, D.
Abstract

A recent report published by the Local Government Association (LGA), ‘Children in Trouble', calls for the abolition of youth custody for ‘all but violent offenders, drastically slashing the number of young people locked up by around 4000' (2006, p1). Such a move, the authors say, would represent a 65 per cent fall in the young prison population and save over £70m a year. The report was publicly welcomed by spokespersons for the charities NACRO and the Howard League for Penal Reform both of which have issued similar demands for a reduction in custody in recent months and years, alongside other campaigning organizations and a number of criminologists. The reasons cited are familiar: imprisoning young people is relatively expensive, frequently harmful to their longer term welfare and largely ineffective in terms of tackling re-offending. Whilst custody should remain the default option for children and young people who pose a serious risk to others, the majority should be subject to community based sanctions.
There is much to agree with in the LGA report and I should preface what follows by stating that nothing of what I write is intended to diminish the importance of reducing the imprisonment of children and young people. However, if this goal is to be realised, as the LGA acknowledges, then there must be viable community based alternatives in place, not least because there is a considerable constituency that doubts that this is possible or desirable. With this in mind, this article discusses the ups and downs of one form of community based work with young offenders, mentoring. In the space of about ten years, this has become an integral element of provision across the spectrum of youth justice. There are preventative mentoring schemes targeting young children designated at-risk and there are re-integrative schemes in which mentors are matched with young people whilst in custody so as to provide a form of support on release. And yet, at a point where the hundreds of new mentoring schemes established in recent years can be reasonably expected to have bedded down, with systems for referral, training, matching and so on in place, recent research, to be discussed below, has raised question marks over its effectiveness such that its transition from being ‘what's promising' to ‘what works' looks in doubt. Reflecting on this turn of events, the article revisits the context in and process by which mentoring grew to prominence and suggests that factors such as marketing and rebranding might have had a more important role than impartial research evidence.

PublisherHM Prison Service
JournalPrison Service Journal
ISSN0300-3558
Publication dates
PrintMar 2007
Publication process dates
Deposited14 Sep 2009
Output statusPublished
Web address (URL)http://www.hmprisonservice.gov.uk/assets/documents/100027C3mentoring.pdf
LanguageEnglish
Permalink -

https://repository.mdx.ac.uk/item/81w83

  • 25
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 0
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

"If I had had a me": the benefits and challenges of involving children with lived experience in youth justice services
Porteous, D. and Goodman, A. 2023. "If I had had a me": the benefits and challenges of involving children with lived experience in youth justice services. Safer Communities. 22 (3), pp. 172-185. https://doi.org/10.1108/SC-10-2022-0043
An evaluation of Youth Ink: Interim report
Goodman, A. and Porteous, D. 2022. An evaluation of Youth Ink: Interim report. England and Wales Youth Justice Board for England and Wales.
Supporting offenders who are also victims [Blog post]
Porteous, D. 2015. Supporting offenders who are also victims [Blog post]. MDX Minds Middlesex University.
Appendix A: Offending and victimisation, pathways and interventions: literature review for YJB victims reference group
Porteous, D. 2016. Appendix A: Offending and victimisation, pathways and interventions: literature review for YJB victims reference group. London Youth Justice Board.
The Portuguese-speaking community in Lambeth: a scoping study
Melo Nogueira, M., Porteous, D. and Guerreiro, S. 2015. The Portuguese-speaking community in Lambeth: a scoping study. London London Community Foundation.
Book Review [Heroin and music in New York City by Barry Spunt]
Porteous, D. 2015. Book Review [Heroin and music in New York City by Barry Spunt]. Drugs: Education, Prevention, and Policy. 22 (6), p. 489. https://doi.org/10.3109/09687637.2015.1033882
The development of specialist support services for young people who have offended and who have also been victims of crime, abuse and/or violence: final report
Porteous, D., Adler, J. and Davidson, J. 2015. The development of specialist support services for young people who have offended and who have also been victims of crime, abuse and/or violence: final report. London MOPAC.
Utopian youth justice?
Porteous, D. 2014. Utopian youth justice?
Insiders? The experiences and perspectives of long-term, regular cannabis users
Chatwin, C. and Porteous, D. 2013. Insiders? The experiences and perspectives of long-term, regular cannabis users. Contemporary Drug Problems. 40 (2), pp. 235-258.
Going green
Chatwin, C. and Porteous, D. 2011. Going green. Druglink. 26 (6), pp. 12-13.
Good cop, Polish cop: findings from an evaluation of the secondment of two Polish police officers to work with the Metropolitan Police
Porteous, D. 2011. Good cop, Polish cop: findings from an evaluation of the secondment of two Polish police officers to work with the Metropolitan Police. Safer Communities. 10 (2), pp. 32-41. https://doi.org/10.5042/sc.2011.0184
An evaluation of the NCY Trust teenage parenting project
Porteous, D. 2010. An evaluation of the NCY Trust teenage parenting project. Middlesex University Middlesex University.
Stopped, searched and (reasonably) suspicious: young people’s experiences of pro-active policing
Puniskis, M., Porteous, D. and Goodman, S. 2010. Stopped, searched and (reasonably) suspicious: young people’s experiences of pro-active policing. 2nd Annual Postgraduate Criminology Conference. Cambridge, UK 30 Sep - 01 Oct 2010
Young victims of street crime in an East London borough.
Porteous, D., Chatwin, C., Martin, D. and Goodman, A. 2007. Young victims of street crime in an East London borough. Safety Communities. 6 (3), pp. 29-35.
The wrong kind of victim? Children and street crime
Porteous, D. 2008. The wrong kind of victim? Children and street crime. in: Kennison, P. and Goodman, A. (ed.) Children as victims Exeter, UK Learning Matters.
The prevention of youth crime: a risky business?
Porteous, D. 2007. The prevention of youth crime: a risky business? in: Thom, B., Sales, R. and Pearce, J. (ed.) Growing up with risk Bristol Policy Press. pp. 259-276
Mentoring in youth justice
Porteous, D. 2005. Mentoring in youth justice. in: Bateman, T. and Pitts, J. (ed.) The RHP companion to youth justice Lyme Regis Russell House.
Mentoring
Porteous, D. 2001. Mentoring. in: Factor, F., Chauhan, V. and Pitts, J. (ed.) The Russell House companion to working with young people Lyme Regis Russell House.
Working with young people in Europe: what we can learn from our neighbours
Voland, B. and Porteous, D. 2002. Working with young people in Europe: what we can learn from our neighbours. Russell House.
The socio-cultural characteristics and needs of a Portuguese community in South London
Noguiera, M. and Porteous, D. 2004. The socio-cultural characteristics and needs of a Portuguese community in South London. in: Abreu, G., Cline, T. and Lambert, H. (ed.) The education of Portuguese children in Britain: insights from research and practice in England and overseas: proceedings from the working conference organised in November 2001 at the University of Luton, England. London, UK Portuguese Education Department. pp. 51-74
Averting ghettoisation: the role of educational services in reducing crime and victimisation in the ethnic minority community in Anderlecht, Brussels
Porteous, D. and Pitts, J. 2006. Averting ghettoisation: the role of educational services in reducing crime and victimisation in the ethnic minority community in Anderlecht, Brussels. Community Safety Journal. 5 (3), pp. 7-13.
`Nobody should feel alone.' Re-introducing socially excluded, cultural and ethnic minority children and young people to educational and vocational opportunity
Porteous, D. and Pitts, J. 2005. `Nobody should feel alone.' Re-introducing socially excluded, cultural and ethnic minority children and young people to educational and vocational opportunity. European Journal of Social Work. 8 (4), pp. 435-450. https://doi.org/10.1080/13691450500314103
Risky or at risk? Young people, surveillance and security
Porteous, D., Chatwin, C. and Martin, D. 2007. Risky or at risk? Young people, surveillance and security. Criminal Justice Matters. 68 (1), pp. 27-28. https://doi.org/10.1080/09627250708553281