Observations critiques sur l'exclusivité proclamée des sources formelles du droit dans la jurisprudence administrative

Article

Bernaz, N. 2007. Observations critiques sur l'exclusivité proclamée des sources formelles du droit dans la jurisprudence administrative. Revue de la Recherche Juridique: droit prospectif. 2, pp. 833-852.
TypeArticle
TitleObservations critiques sur l'exclusivité proclamée des sources formelles du droit dans la jurisprudence administrative
AuthorsBernaz, N.
Abstract

The paper explores the use of different sources of law by the French highest administrative court, the Conseil d'Etat. In civil law tradition countries, such as France, the judgements are short and non detailed, giving the misleading impression that statutes are exclusively used to reach decisions. The paper argues that, just like common law judges, French judges use other sources as well during their decision making process, from non binding soft law to foreign law.

Research GroupLaw and Politics
PublisherPresses universitaires d'Aix-Marseille
JournalRevue de la Recherche Juridique: droit prospectif
ISSN0249-8731
Publication dates
Print01 Jan 2007
Publication process dates
Deposited08 Mar 2010
Output statusPublished
LanguageEnglish
Permalink -

https://repository.mdx.ac.uk/item/82543

Log in to edit
  • 32
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 4
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Business and Human Rights and the developing notion of corporate criminal liability under international law
Bernaz, N. 2016. Business and Human Rights and the developing notion of corporate criminal liability under international law. Research Workshop on Business & Human Rights. Copenhagen Business School, Denmark 20 May 2016
Maximising the impact of the Future Business and Human Rights treaty
Bernaz, N. 2016. Maximising the impact of the Future Business and Human Rights treaty. Human Rights Interest Group Roundtable, American Society of International Law. George Washington University, Washington DC 29 Mar 2016
The death penalty. a worldwide perspective [Book Review]
Bernaz, N. 2016. The death penalty. a worldwide perspective [Book Review]. The Irish Jurist. 55, pp. 217-219.
Guest post: General Court of the European Union annuls the EU-Morocco Free Trade Agreement on human rights grounds but forgets self-determination
Bernaz, N. and Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2015. Guest post: General Court of the European Union annuls the EU-Morocco Free Trade Agreement on human rights grounds but forgets self-determination. Opinio Juris.
Business and human rights: history, law and policy – bridging the accountability gap
Bernaz, N. 2016. Business and human rights: history, law and policy – bridging the accountability gap. London and New York Routledge.
Review of D. Karp, 'Responsibility for human rights, transnational corporations in imperfect state'
Bernaz, N. 2016. Review of D. Karp, 'Responsibility for human rights, transnational corporations in imperfect state'. Business and Human Rights Journal. 1 (1), pp. 165-168. https://doi.org/10.1017/bhj.2015.10
Including corporate criminal liability for international crimes in the future Business and Human Rights Treaty
Bernaz, N. 2015. Including corporate criminal liability for international crimes in the future Business and Human Rights Treaty. Debating the Treaty on Business and Human Rights. Universidad Autonoma de Madrid (Spain) 26 Jun 2015
Resources grabbing and human rights: building a triangular relationship between states, indigenous peoples and corporations
Bernaz, N. and Gilbert, J. 2015. Resources grabbing and human rights: building a triangular relationship between states, indigenous peoples and corporations. in: Bonfanti, A., Romanin Jacur, F. and Seatzu, F. (ed.) Natural Resources Grabbing: An International Law Perspective De Gruyter Brill.
Corporate criminal liability under international law: the new TV S.A.L. and Akhbar Beirut S.A.L. cases at the Special Tribunal for Lebanon
Bernaz, N. 2015. Corporate criminal liability under international law: the new TV S.A.L. and Akhbar Beirut S.A.L. cases at the Special Tribunal for Lebanon. Journal of International Criminal Justice. 13 (2), pp. 313-330. https://doi.org/10.1093/jicj/mqv014
Business and human rights [book section]
Bernaz, N. 2015. Business and human rights [book section]. in: Westlaw UK Insight Westlaw UK.
Business and human rights [lecture, London, UK]
Bernaz, N. 2015. Business and human rights [lecture, London, UK]. Matrix Chambers and Middlesex University Short Course on Human Rights. The Law Society of England and Wales, London, UK 13 Apr 2015
The death penalty in international law and politics
Bernaz, N. 2014. The death penalty in international law and politics. Matrix Chambers and Middlesex University Short Course on Human Rights. Matrix Chambers, London, UK 21 Jan 2014
The extraterritorial obligations of states in the area of business and human rights
Bernaz, N. 2013. The extraterritorial obligations of states in the area of business and human rights. N/A. Norwegian Centre for Human Rights, University of Oslo (Norway) 26 Nov 2013
Should multinational corporations be held liable for having done business with the apartheid regime?
Bernaz, N. 2013. Should multinational corporations be held liable for having done business with the apartheid regime? N/A. South African Institute for Advanced Constitutional, Public, Human Rights and International Law (SAIFAC) University of Johannesburg 23 Oct 2013
Should multinational corporations be held liable for having done business with the apartheid regime?
Bernaz, N. 2013. Should multinational corporations be held liable for having done business with the apartheid regime? N/A. University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg (South Africa) 14 Oct 2013
Business and human rights [lecture, Paris, France]
Bernaz, N. 2013. Business and human rights [lecture, Paris, France]. N/A. Chamber of Commerce, Paris (France) 27 May 2013
Business and human rights: selected issues [2014]
Bernaz, N. 2014. Business and human rights: selected issues [2014]. N/A. HEC Paris (France) 26 Mar 2014
Business and human rights: selected issues [2013]
Bernaz, N. 2013. Business and human rights: selected issues [2013]. N/A. HEC Paris (France) 06 Mar 2013
Corporate crimes and the ICC Statute
Bernaz, N. 2012. Corporate crimes and the ICC Statute. Summer School on Corporate Social Responsibility. European School of Law and Governance, Brdo (Slovenia) 30 Aug 2012
Corporate crimes and the ICC Statute
Bernaz, N. 2014. Corporate crimes and the ICC Statute. International Criminal Court Summer School (ICC) Summer School. Irish Centre for Human Rights, Galway, Ireland 16 - 20 Jun 2014
Corporate crimes and the ICC Statute
Bernaz, N. 2013. Corporate crimes and the ICC Statute. ICC Summer School. Irish Centre for Human Rights, Galway (Ireland) Jun 2013
Corporate crimes and the ICC Statute
Bernaz, N. 2012. Corporate crimes and the ICC Statute. ICC Summer School. Irish Centre for Human Rights, Galway (Ireland) Jun 2012
International criminal law and Iraq
Bernaz, N. 2012. International criminal law and Iraq. N/A. University of Duhok (Iraq) 06 Feb 2012
Business and human rights: the impossible reconciliation?
Bernaz, N. 2011. Business and human rights: the impossible reconciliation? N/A. University of the West Indies, Kingston (Jamaica) 14 Nov 2011
The historical evolution of international criminal law
Bernaz, N. 2011. The historical evolution of international criminal law. Visit of Middlesex Academics. University of Duhok (Iraq) 31 Mar 2011
Reparations for slavery: the international law perspective
Bernaz, N. 2014. Reparations for slavery: the international law perspective. Historians and the Reparations Movement. University College London 10 Sep 2014
The significance of Soering to the international law on capital punishment
Bernaz, N. 2014. The significance of Soering to the international law on capital punishment. Soering after twenty five years. Gray's Inn, London, UK 20 Jun 2014
Business and Human Rights Treaty: the sceptic view
Bernaz, N. 2014. Business and Human Rights Treaty: the sceptic view. Does the World Need a Treaty on Business and Human Rights? Weighing the Pros and Cons. Notre Dame School of Law, London, UK 14 May 2014
Corporate accountability for human rights violations in countries in transition
Bernaz, N. 2014. Corporate accountability for human rights violations in countries in transition. 9 Bedford Row International Conference: Human Rights in Post-Revolution States and Human Rights at Sea. HMS President, London, UK 03 Apr 2014
Resources grabbing and human rights: building a triangular relationship between states, indigenous peoples and corporations
Bernaz, N. and Gilbert, J. 2013. Resources grabbing and human rights: building a triangular relationship between states, indigenous peoples and corporations. Natural Resources Grabbing: Erosion or Legitimate Exercise of State Sovereignty. University of Cagliari (Italy) 04 Oct 2013
The politics of the death penalty in countries in transition
Bernaz, N. 2013. The politics of the death penalty in countries in transition. Law Postgraduate Conference. University of Greenwich (London) 06 Jun 2013
The future of extraterritorial jurisdiction
Bernaz, N. 2013. The future of extraterritorial jurisdiction. Teaching Business and Human Rights. Columbia Law School (New York) 31 May 2013
Addressing slave labour in supply chains through reporting
Bernaz, N. 2013. Addressing slave labour in supply chains through reporting. Business and Human Rights Interest Group, European Society of International Law Conference. University of Amsterdam, Netherlands 23 May 2013
Assessing diplomatic assurances in the context of extradition and transfer of individuals to States where they can be subjected to the death penalty
Bernaz, N. 2012. Assessing diplomatic assurances in the context of extradition and transfer of individuals to States where they can be subjected to the death penalty. Expert meeting organised by the UN Special Rapporteurs on Torture and Extrajudicial Executions. Harvard University School of Law 25 - 26 Jun 2012
Extra-territoriality as a way to enhance corporate accountability for human rights violations committed abroad
Bernaz, N. 2012. Extra-territoriality as a way to enhance corporate accountability for human rights violations committed abroad. Ireland and the United Nations Framework for Business and Human Rights. Irish Centre for Human Rights, National University of Ireland Galway 24 Mar 2012
Detention in conflict: an international criminal law perspective
Bernaz, N. 2011. Detention in conflict: an international criminal law perspective. Side-event on Detention in Conflict at the 17th Session of the UN Human Rights Council. United Nations, Geneva 31 May 2011
Delivering justice in the Caribbean: a human rights assessment of the Caribbean Court of Justice
Bernaz, N. 2011. Delivering justice in the Caribbean: a human rights assessment of the Caribbean Court of Justice. SLSA Annual Conference 2011. Sussex Law School, Brighton 13 Apr 2011
The international protection against inhuman or degrading punishment
Bernaz, N. 2010. The international protection against inhuman or degrading punishment. Forgotten Rights Forgotten Concepts. Irish Centre for Human Rights, NUI Galway 19 - 20 Nov 2010
Responding to vulnerability: can state and corporation be business partners?
Bernaz, N. 2010. Responding to vulnerability: can state and corporation be business partners? Vulnerability and the corporation workshop. Emory University School of Law 28 - 29 Oct 2010
Cultures, religions and capital punishment
Bernaz, N. 2009. Cultures, religions and capital punishment. International Symposium on the Universal Abolition of the Death Penalty. University of Madrid 11 Dec 2009
American exceptionalism and the United Nations: the example of the death penalty
Bernaz, N. 2009. American exceptionalism and the United Nations: the example of the death penalty. American Exceptionalism and Human Rights. Free University Brussels 26 Nov 2009
Human rights: the legal issues facing businesses
Bernaz, N. 2009. Human rights: the legal issues facing businesses. Friday Forum on Human Rights: how far should companies go. Association of Chartered Certified Accountants 13 Nov 2009
Guidance on business and human rights: a review
Bernaz, N. and Gilbert, J. 2011. Guidance on business and human rights: a review. Equality and Human Rights Commission.
Establishing liability for financial complicity in international crimes
Bernaz, N. 2014. Establishing liability for financial complicity in international crimes. in: Bohoslavsky, J. and Letnar Cernic, J. (ed.) Making sovereign financing and human rights work Hart. pp. 61-76
Transitional processes and the death penalty in North Africa
Boubakri, A. and Bernaz, N. 2013. Transitional processes and the death penalty in North Africa. in: Futamura, M. and Bernaz, N. (ed.) The Politics of the Death Penalty in Countries in Transition Routledge. pp. 203-216
Continuing evolution of the United Nations treaty bodies system
Bernaz, N. 2013. Continuing evolution of the United Nations treaty bodies system. in: Rodley, N. and Sheeran, S. (ed.) Routledge Handbook of International Human Rights Law Routledge. pp. 707-724
Enhancing corporate accountability for human rights violations: is extraterritoriality the magic potion?
Bernaz, N. 2012. Enhancing corporate accountability for human rights violations: is extraterritoriality the magic potion? Journal of Business Ethics. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-012-1531-z
Life imprisonment and the prohibition of inhuman punishments in international human rights law: moving the agenda forward
Bernaz, N. 2013. Life imprisonment and the prohibition of inhuman punishments in international human rights law: moving the agenda forward. Human Rights Quarterly. 35 (2), pp. 470-497. https://doi.org/10.1353/hrq.2013.0029
Delivering justice in the Caribbean: a human rights assessment of the Caribbean Court of Justice
Bernaz, N. 2012. Delivering justice in the Caribbean: a human rights assessment of the Caribbean Court of Justice. Public Law. 2012 (Oct), pp. 703-723.
Sentencing and penalties
Bernaz, N. 2011. Sentencing and penalties. in: Schabas, W. and Bernaz, N. (ed.) Routledge Handbook of International Criminal Law London Routledge. pp. 289-303
La Cour de Justice caraïbe: une juridiction inclassable
Bernaz, N. 2010. La Cour de Justice caraïbe: une juridiction inclassable. L’Observateur des Nations Unies. 24, pp. 65-82.
Le Sommet mondial pour le développement durable de Johanesbourg, un sommet de plus?
Bernaz, N. and Capitani, F. 2002. Le Sommet mondial pour le développement durable de Johanesbourg, un sommet de plus? L’Observateur des Nations Unies.
Les incohérences de l'arrêt Öcalan contre Turquie de la Cour européenne des droits de l'homme dans ses aspects concernant la peine de mort
Bernaz, N. 2003. Les incohérences de l'arrêt Öcalan contre Turquie de la Cour européenne des droits de l'homme dans ses aspects concernant la peine de mort. L’Observateur des Nations Unies.
L'abolition de la peine de mort pour les mineurs aux Etats-Unis: quelques remarques à propos de l'arrêt Roper v. Simmons du 1er mars 2005
Bernaz, N. 2006. L'abolition de la peine de mort pour les mineurs aux Etats-Unis: quelques remarques à propos de l'arrêt Roper v. Simmons du 1er mars 2005. Revue Française de Droit Constitutionnel.
L’ONU et les STN: la nécessité d’une collaboration opérationnelle en matière de droits sociaux internationaux
Bernaz, N. and Morin, P. 2005. L’ONU et les STN: la nécessité d’une collaboration opérationnelle en matière de droits sociaux internationaux. in: Boisson de Chazournes, L. and Mehdi, R. (ed.) Une société internationale en mutation, quels acteurs pour une nouvelle gouvernance? Brussels Bruylant.
Sentencing in international criminal law: the need for clear standards
Bernaz, N. 2008. Sentencing in international criminal law: the need for clear standards. Codifying the Criminal Law: Modern Initiatives. Dublin, Ireland 2008
The role of the European Union in the Human Rights Council
Wouters, J., Basu, S. and Bernaz, N. 2008. The role of the European Union in the Human Rights Council. Venice EIUC - European Inter University Centre.
The Caribbean court of justice: one court with two jurisdictions: a unique judicial institution?
Bernaz, N. 2008. The Caribbean court of justice: one court with two jurisdictions: a unique judicial institution? International Law Colloquium Series. University of Georgia School of Law, Athens, United States 15 Feb 2008
Post conflict justice mechanisms in Europe
Bernaz, N. 2008. Post conflict justice mechanisms in Europe. Fighting Impunity and Promoting International Justice: Thematic Conference. United Nations, Geneva, Switzerland 10 - 11 Nov 2008
Prosecutions as a post conflict justice tool
Bernaz, N. 2009. Prosecutions as a post conflict justice tool. Fighting Impunity and Promoting International Justice. Peace Palace, The Hague, Netherlands 08 Jun 2009
L’exceptionnalisme américain et les Nations Unies: le cas de la peine de mort.
Bernaz, N. 2009. L’exceptionnalisme américain et les Nations Unies: le cas de la peine de mort. in: Hennebel, L. and Van Waeyenberge, A. (ed.) Exceptionnalisme Américain et Droits de L’homme Paris Dalloz. pp. 255-277
International and domestic prosecutions
Bernaz, N. and Prouveze, R. 2010. International and domestic prosecutions. in: Bassiouni, M. (ed.) The Pursuit of International Criminal Justice: A World Study on Conflicts, Victimization, and Post-Conflict Justice Intersentia.
Le droit international et la peine de mort
Bernaz, N. 2008. Le droit international et la peine de mort. Paris La Documentation Francaise.
Reforming the UN human rights protection procedures: a legal perspective on the establishment of the Universal Periodic Review mechanism
Bernaz, N. 2009. Reforming the UN human rights protection procedures: a legal perspective on the establishment of the Universal Periodic Review mechanism. in: Boyle, K. (ed.) New Institutions for Human Rights Protection Oxford Oxford University Press (OUP).