Gender, language and floor apportionment in political debates

Article


Shaw, S. 2000. Gender, language and floor apportionment in political debates. Discourse and Society. 11 (3), pp. 401-418. https://doi.org/10.1177/0957926500011003006
TypeArticle
TitleGender, language and floor apportionment in political debates
AuthorsShaw, S.
Abstract

Political debates are speech events which foreground issues of power and the `floor', and allow the opportunity of assessing the ways in which the gender of participants affects their construction as more or less powerful participants in debates. Debates in the British House of Commons are adversarial in style, making it appropriate to view the floor as `the site of a contest where there is a winner and a loser'. Previous research into political debates has found that male participants violate the formal rules in debates more than their female counterparts, in order to gain the floor. Although the canonical form and rules of debates exist to `permit the equalization of turns', rule violations are common, and inequalities between participants exist. In this article legal and illegal interventions are evaluated in five debates in order to establish the extent to which the gender of participants is related to the control that an individual has over the debate floor.

Research GroupEnglish Language and Literature
PublisherSage
JournalDiscourse and Society
ISSN0957-9265
Publication dates
Print01 Jul 2000
Publication process dates
Deposited04 May 2010
Output statusPublished
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1177/0957926500011003006
LanguageEnglish
Permalink -

https://repository.mdx.ac.uk/item/829y3

  • 37
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 2
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Embedding employability in English programmes
Clark, B., Charalambidou, A. and Shaw, S. 2016. Embedding employability in English programmes. HEA's annual Arts and Humanities conference: Inspire - sharing great practice in Arts and Humanities teaching and learning. Brighton, UK 03 - 04 Mar 2016
Changing the debate? Women and language in the UK General Election
Cameron, D. and Shaw, S. 2016. Changing the debate? Women and language in the UK General Election. Babel: The Language Magazine. 14, pp. 33-37.
Celebrity capital in the political field: Russell Brand's migration from stand-up comedy to Newsnight
Arthurs, J. and Shaw, S. 2016. Celebrity capital in the political field: Russell Brand's migration from stand-up comedy to Newsnight. Media Culture and Society. 38 (8), pp. 1136-1152. https://doi.org/10.1177/0163443716635869
Winning and losing the ‘battle for number 10’: a linguistic analysis of the Paxman vs Cameron/Miliband election interviews
Shaw, S. 2015. Winning and losing the ‘battle for number 10’: a linguistic analysis of the Paxman vs Cameron/Miliband election interviews. in: Jackson, D. and Thorsen, E. (ed.) UK Election Analysis 2015: Media, Voters and the Campaign: Early reflections from leading UK academics Poole, England Centre for the Study of Journalism, Culture and Community Bournemouth University. pp. 22
Gender and politics in the devolved assemblies
Shaw, S. 2013. Gender and politics in the devolved assemblies. Soundings: a journal of politics and culture. https://doi.org/10.3898/136266213809450301
An ethnographic investigation into gender and language in the Northern Ireland Assembly
Shaw, S. 2013. An ethnographic investigation into gender and language in the Northern Ireland Assembly. in: Poggi, I., D'Errico, F., Vincze, L. and Vinciarelli, A. (ed.) Multimodal Communication in Political Speech. Shaping Minds and Social Action: International Workshop, Political Speech 2010, Rome, Italy, November 10-12, 2010, revised selected papers Springer.
'I am not an Honourable Lady': gender and language in the National Assembly for Wales
Shaw, S. 2011. 'I am not an Honourable Lady': gender and language in the National Assembly for Wales. Journal of Applied Linguistics and Professional Practice. 8 (3), pp. 275-294.
Too polite to fight? What happens when women enter the House?
Shaw, S. 2008. Too polite to fight? What happens when women enter the House? emagazine.
Language and gender in political debates in the House of Commons
Shaw, S. 2002. Language and gender in political debates in the House of Commons. PhD thesis The Institute of Education, University of London Culture, Communication and Media
The linguistic participation of women in the ‘new’ devolved assemblies of the UK: What can it tell us, and how can we measure it?
Shaw, S. 2011. The linguistic participation of women in the ‘new’ devolved assemblies of the UK: What can it tell us, and how can we measure it? Representing Women: Images, Discourses and Realities in Irish Political Life. Dublin City University, Dublin. 15 Sep 2011
Speaking about speeches: interviews with women politicians about linguistic practices in UK parliamentary debates
Shaw, S. 2011. Speaking about speeches: interviews with women politicians about linguistic practices in UK parliamentary debates. The 12th International Pragmatics Conference (IPRA). Manchester University 03 - 08 Jul 2011
'I am not an Honourable Lady': the construction of national and gendered identities in the National Assembly for Wales.
Shaw, S. 2011. 'I am not an Honourable Lady': the construction of national and gendered identities in the National Assembly for Wales. The First Applied Linguistics and Professional Practice (ALAPP) Conference. Cardiff, Wales 23 - 24 Jun 2011
New parliaments, new practices? An account of gender and language in the devolved parliaments of the UK
Shaw, S. 2011. New parliaments, new practices? An account of gender and language in the devolved parliaments of the UK. Parliamentary Discourses Across Cultures: Interdisciplinary Approaches. Bucharest, Romania 23 - 24 Sep 2011
Discourses of differentiation: gender and participation in the devolved parliaments of the UK
Shaw, S. 2012. Discourses of differentiation: gender and participation in the devolved parliaments of the UK. The Political Science Association (PSA) Women and Politics Bi-annual Conference 2012, 'Making a Difference for Women'. University of Bristol and the West of England, Bristol 18 Feb 2012
Gender and linguistic participation in the devolved parliaments of the UK : interview data
Shaw, S. 2012. Gender and linguistic participation in the devolved parliaments of the UK : interview data. UK Data Archive.
Researching gender at work: possibilities and constraints
Litosseliti, L., Angouri, J., Baxter, J., Mullany, L. and Shaw, S. 2012. Researching gender at work: possibilities and constraints. •IGALA 7, Seventh International Gender and Language Association Conference. UNISINOS, São Leopoldo, Brazil 20 - 22 Jun 2012
Demystifying the contents and construction of dictionaries.
Shaw, S. 1999. Demystifying the contents and construction of dictionaries. in: Wheeler, R. (ed.) Language alive in the classroom. London Praeger. pp. 189-199
Politics of performance: rhetoric and political speech
Shaw, S., Bajpai, R. and Finlayson, A. 2008. Politics of performance: rhetoric and political speech. 1st Annual Conference of Gendered Ritual and Ceremony in Parliament (GCRP). Warwick University 23 - 24 Oct 2008
Governed by the rules? The female voice in parliamentary debates
Shaw, S. 2006. Governed by the rules? The female voice in parliamentary debates. in: Baxter, J. (ed.) Speaking out: the female voice in public contexts Basingstoke Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 81-102
The difference women make: a critique of the notion of a 'women's style' of speech in political contexts
Shaw, S. 2009. The difference women make: a critique of the notion of a 'women's style' of speech in political contexts. 42nd Annual Meeting of the British Association of Applied Linguistics (BAAL). Newcastle 03 - 05 Sep 2009
An ethnographic and linguistic investigation into the construction of an individual’s ‘unpopularity’ on the debating floor of the Northern Ireland Assembly
Shaw, S. 2010. An ethnographic and linguistic investigation into the construction of an individual’s ‘unpopularity’ on the debating floor of the Northern Ireland Assembly. Political speech – Il parlato politico. University Roma Tre, Rome, Italy 10 - 12 Nov 2010