Embodiments of evil and reflections of social change in second-world fantasy

Book chapter


Dalton, A. 2019. Embodiments of evil and reflections of social change in second-world fantasy. in: Barbini, F. (ed.) A shadow within: evil in Fantasy and Science Fiction Edinburgh Luna Press Publishing. pp. 73-101
Chapter titleEmbodiments of evil and reflections of social change in second-world fantasy
AuthorsDalton, A.
Abstract

It was the New Testament of the Bible that first presented us with Satan as ‘the Dark Lord’ (Dalton, Forthcoming), a malign figure who sought to suborn and corrupt innocents, thereby to create widespread social upheaval, destroy the existing establishment and become the absolute ruler of the kingdom himself. For two millennia, this Dark Lord was considered to be an entirely real, imminent, and serious threat to humanity and any possibility of the establishment of God’s holy kingdom on earth. There was nothing entertaining about him whatsoever, as he imperilled our very souls. However, towards the end of the nineteenth century, with the emergence of science fiction and fantasy (SFF) as distinct literary genres, the Dark Lord became enshrined in popular works of fiction.
From Bram Stoker’s Dracula, to Tolkien’s Sauron, to Donaldson’s Lord Foul, to Lucas’s Darth Vader, the Dark Lord was ever present in SFF. Sometimes he was a mad god, evil emperor or evil corporation, but always there was that malign intelligence seeking to thwart the goody-goody Chosen One (white knight) of the 1980s and 90s. The Dark Lord had servants, in the form of demon armies, alien invaders or intelligent machines, seeking to drag the unwary into the underworld, to conquer us or to make humanity entirely extinct. Yet, significantly, the Dark Lord was always defeated, and the threat to ourselves was far less real, imminent or serious than we had once thought.
Come the new millennium, and the emergence of subgenres like ‘grimdark fantasy’ and ‘dystopian YA’, we tend to see everything in shades of grey far more. We still have invading hordes, be they zombies or Dothraki, but they are mindless disease-carriers and immigrants-with-a-cause rather than out-and-out followers of Satan. Our sense of evil has changed. We seem to understand that ‘evil’ is really a matter of perspective. And what has become of ‘the Dark Lord’ himself? Well, he is now the star of TV series such as ‘Lucifer’ or ‘Dracula’. Has he actually changed from antihero into hero? Has he won in some way? Or do we now recognise ourselves in him? Were we really fighting against ourselves all along?
This article considers the character of the Dark Lord and other embodiments of evil within fantasy literature in order to show how our idea of evil has changed over time, to identify how the genre has shifted (via new subgenres) since its early days, to consider emerging trends and, perhaps, to help us better understand ourselves. Initially, the article demonstrates how our understanding of the Satanic (or what is ‘wrong’ with the world and ourselves) develops and evolves with each different socio-historical moment by comparing Tolkien’s ‘high fantasy’ to subsequent ‘epic fantasy’. That comparison is enabled by a summary of the difference in characterisation, literary style, plot organisation, and themes of the two subgenres, and a description of the difference in underlying personal and social values of the two subgenres.
Having analysed and discussed the differing relationship to the Satanic in ‘high fantasy’ and ‘epic fantasy’, the article considers developments in the above relationship as represented in the ‘metaphysical fantasy’ and ‘dark fantasy’ subgenres of the early 2000s and the subsequent ‘grimdark fantasy’1 and ‘dystopian YA’ subgenres of the 2010s. That will bring us up to now, and then we must consider where we stand… or kneel. [A J Dalton, Lecturer, Middlesex University]

Research GroupEnglish Language and Literature
LanguageEnglish
Page range73-101
Book titleA shadow within: evil in Fantasy and Science Fiction
EditorsBarbini, F.
PublisherLuna Press Publishing
Place of publicationEdinburgh
ISBN
Paperback9781911143918
Electronic9781911143925
Publication dates
Print14 Aug 2019
Publication process dates
Deposited12 Nov 2019
Accepted31 Dec 2018
Output statusPublished
Copyright Statement

Articles © is with each individual author 2019
First published by Luna Press Publishing, Edinburgh, 2019
The attached document is the published version of a chapter published by Luna Press Publishing. Permission was granted In April 2020 by Luna Press Publishing (www.lunapresspublishing.com) to make the full text available in this repository after an embargo.

Web address (URL)https://www.lunapresspublishing.com/product-page/a-shadow-within-evil-in-fantasy-and-science-fiction
Permalink -

https://repository.mdx.ac.uk/item/8896w

Restricted files

Publisher's version

  • 30
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 2
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

The Nekra
Dalton, A. 2024. The Nekra. Science Fiction Poetry Association.
Four speculative poems: 'Soulless', 'Simulant', 'Celestial Sound and Light Show', 'The Worm'
Dalton, A. 2024. Four speculative poems: 'Soulless', 'Simulant', 'Celestial Sound and Light Show', 'The Worm'. Starship Sloane Publishing.
With a Biochecker, you'll never be ill again
Dalton, A. 2024. With a Biochecker, you'll never be ill again. Starship Sloane Publishing.
Geo-political vampirism: how and why has Western literary scholarship appropriated and then re-mythologised the socio-historical origins of the vampire?
Dalton, A. 2024. Geo-political vampirism: how and why has Western literary scholarship appropriated and then re-mythologised the socio-historical origins of the vampire? Humanities and Social Sciences Communications. 11 (1). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-023-02576-z
Four horror poems: 'Lords of the Nekra', 'Revenant', 'Implant', 'Overdue Barbecue'
Dalton, A. 2024. Four horror poems: 'Lords of the Nekra', 'Revenant', 'Implant', 'Overdue Barbecue'. Siren's Call Publications.
Two speculative poems: 'Unwind' and 'Surface Tension'
Dalton, A. 2024. Two speculative poems: 'Unwind' and 'Surface Tension'. Science Fiction Poetry Association.
Resetting
Dalton, A. 2023. Resetting.
The Final Saga
Dalton, A. 2023. The Final Saga. Sigil House Productions.
Recipe
Dalton, A. 2023. Recipe. Science Fiction Poetry Association.
Digital Desire
Dalton, A. 2023. Digital Desire. Science Fiction Poetry Association.
I, Medusa
Dalton, A.J. 2023. I, Medusa. Illustrated Worlds Magazine.
The Nekrascape
Dalton, A. 2023. The Nekrascape. Altered Reality Magazine.
The unreliable socio-visual performance and identity of a novelist
Dalton, A. 2023. The unreliable socio-visual performance and identity of a novelist. BlueHouse Journal.
We are on the hill: Research Project: Episode 5: Henry Philip Creese and the Titanic
Dalton, A. 2019. We are on the hill: Research Project: Episode 5: Henry Philip Creese and the Titanic.
We are on the hill: Research Project: Episode 1: Sir John Gay Newton Alleyne
Dalton, A. 2019. We are on the hill: Research Project: Episode 1: Sir John Gay Newton Alleyne.
Narrative perspective
Dalton, A. 2015. Narrative perspective. in: Royle, N. (ed.) The Art of the Novel Salt Publishing. pp. 32-39
The Book of Witches
Dalton, A. 2020. The Book of Witches. Hempton Kristell Ink.
What is so fabulous about Smaug?
Dalton, A. 2022. What is so fabulous about Smaug? in: Barbini, F. (ed.) Not the Fellowship. Dragons Welcome! Luna Press Publishing.
The book of demons
Dalton, A. 2021. The book of demons. Hempton Kristell Ink.
Unicorn Rising
Dalton, A. 2023. Unicorn Rising. Illustrated Worlds Magazine.
Five poems by A J Dalton: Loki's Lament, Viking Winter, The Misery and Mirth of Mjolnir, Odin Wayfarer, A Girl's Vision
Dalton, A. 2023. Five poems by A J Dalton: Loki's Lament, Viking Winter, The Misery and Mirth of Mjolnir, Odin Wayfarer, A Girl's Vision. Lothlorien Poetry Journal.
Valkyrie Love
Dalton, A. 2023. Valkyrie Love. Songs of Eretz Poetry Review.
Religion in fantasy: propaganda, blasphemy or nonsense?
Dalton, A. 2017. Religion in fantasy: propaganda, blasphemy or nonsense? BFS Journal.
Gender-identity and sexuality in current sub-genres of British fantasy literature: do we have a problem?
Dalton, A. 2017. Gender-identity and sexuality in current sub-genres of British fantasy literature: do we have a problem? in: Barbini, F. (ed.) Gender identity and sexuality in current fantasy and science fiction Edinburgh Luna Press Publishing. pp. 57-82
The decline of the bromance and the rise of human-A.I. relationships in science fiction TV and film
Dalton, A. 2020. The decline of the bromance and the rise of human-A.I. relationships in science fiction TV and film. in: Barbini, F. (ed.) Ties that bind: love in Fantasy and Science Fiction Edinburgh Luna Press Publishing. pp. 52-67
The satanic in science fiction and fantasy
Dalton, A. Barbini, F. (ed.) 2020. The satanic in science fiction and fantasy. Edinburgh Luna Press Publishing.
Empire of the saviours
Dalton, A. 2012. Empire of the saviours. Gollancz.