Musicology, mediation, metatonality: Rethinking the music of Rebecca Clarke and Erwin Schulhoff

Book chapter


Dromey, C. 2021. Musicology, mediation, metatonality: Rethinking the music of Rebecca Clarke and Erwin Schulhoff. in: Fleet, P. (ed.) Musics with and after Tonality: Mining the Gap Routledge. pp. 233–247
Chapter titleMusicology, mediation, metatonality: Rethinking the music of Rebecca Clarke and Erwin Schulhoff
AuthorsDromey, C.
Abstract

Two incontrovertible yet apparently contradictory facts about tonality coexist, and each has a huge influence on how we learn about, perform, hear, and analyse music. The first fact is that, as a conceptual category coined in the early nineteenth century and refined by musicologists of all types ever since, tonality occupies a proud and privileged place in music theory and, by extension, in the telling and retelling of music history. This is why received wisdom continues to teach students that tonality’s ‘evolution’ is a primary factor in the division of musical epochs, and to attune listeners to new thresholds of consonance and dissonance (and, relatedly, of continuities and discontinuities). Such qualities have become central to comprehending and enjoying many kinds of music – a reality that, for better or worse, is ultimately rooted in the concept of tonality being entwined with that of an historicizing narrative almost as soon as it had been conceived. The second fact about tonality highlights a chasm that separates this first set of truths from another: that tonality, for all its significance, is virtually absent in public discourse about music. It is tempting to assume that we simply take tonality for granted; that it is the proverbial invisible hand, shaping countless musical choices, each subject to a vast number of cognitive, personal, and social biases. Similar assumptions have long been fruitful starting points for psychologists and sociologists keen to understand how musical judgements are formed and enacted, and for scholars setting out to disabuse the exceptionalizing notion that Western music between the seventeenth and early twentieth centuries renders other musical cultures and epochs subservient to it because of its tonal framework (Small, 1977). However, the ‘taken for granted’ argument does not adequately recognize the tangible problems that the discussion and teaching of tonality typically pose, nor the interesting implications of such issues for musicologists and pedagogues alike. To compound matters, pedagogical perspectives are rarely examined by musicologists, and this neglect is reciprocated as musicological advances struggle to influence (pre-tertiary) curricula. Two prime features of musicology in the 2010s were to advocate for more equitable representation in music historiography and to fashion a new sense of applied practice, including public-oriented musicologies. Yet, analytical musicology has been slow to embrace such trends. This is not for want of the tools to unpick and celebrate musical accomplishment. Rather, its own august history has evolved alongside wider musicological narratives that have served to narrow its scope of influence and widen the perceived incompatibility of public and analytical knowledge. The power of these narratives (or dogmatic metaphors, as we might describe them, e.g. the ‘death’ of tonality or successive ‘waves’ of modernism) is such that, as Lloyd Whitesell has observed, ‘the cultural symbolism brought to bear on the concept of tonality is extremely telling. As a “common practice” of harmonic conventions, it has the prestige in the minds of many, whether vanguard or conservative, of a repressed, shadow image of modernism’ (Whitesell, 2010, p. 104). The schisms embedded in this quote are as chronologically and thematically relevant to this volume’s ‘with and after’ reading of (meta)tonality as they are to this chapter, which will adopt public-oriented and analytical approaches in order to elucidate certain mediative problems music faces today and to recalibrate our understanding of tonality in the interwar period. The chapter duly explores the subject of tonality from three related perspectives: broadcasting, programme notes, and pedagogy. Then, against this backdrop, it examines two dual-heritage composers, Rebecca Clarke (1886–1979) and Erwin Schulhoff (1894–1942), whose music has deservedly begun to be revived in the last twenty years. The interwar years are generally understood as being crucial to the development of both classical music and musicology. They also marked the tragically brief highpoints of both composers’ careers: Schulhoff was a victim of the Holocaust and suffered critically for his eclecticism; Clarke suffered because of her gender and eventually stopped composing. To rewrite music history by recognizing such neglected composers is not a new challenge, but the perspective of metatonality, being a mutable and referential concept, brings the potential or even the imperative to add a significant new dimension to analytical musicology. This chapter’s structure reflects this by framing its analytical findings with discussion of tonality’s multivalency and of musicology’s modern purpose, including its relationship with the public. In short: how metatonal- inspired readings might help us look afresh at tonality and musicology themselves.

Sustainable Development Goals4 Quality education
Middlesex University ThemeCreativity, Culture & Enterprise
Research GroupMusic group
Page range233–247
Book titleMusics with and after Tonality: Mining the Gap
EditorsFleet, P.
PublisherRoutledge
SeriesAshgate Studies in Theory and Analysis of Music After 1900
ISBN
Hardcover9781138316362
Paperback9781032182865
Electronic9780429451713
Copyright Year2022
Publication dates
Online30 Dec 2021
Print31 Dec 2021
Publication process dates
Accepted2022
Deposited10 Oct 2023
Web address (URL)https://www.routledge.com/Musics-with-and-after-Tonality-Mining-the-Gap/Fleet/p/book/9781138316362
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429451713-11
LanguageEnglish
Permalink -

https://repository.mdx.ac.uk/item/v220v

  • 58
    total views
  • 3
    total downloads
  • 3
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Towards an applied health musicology: Aesthetic music therapy and beyond
Lee, C. A. and Dromey, C. 2023. Towards an applied health musicology: Aesthetic music therapy and beyond. in: Dromey, C. (ed.) The Routledge Companion to Applied Musicology New York Routledge. pp. 184-191
Cultural and artistic citizenship in classical music
Wimmer, C. and Dromey, C. 2023. Cultural and artistic citizenship in classical music. in: Dromey, C. (ed.) The Routledge Companion to Applied Musicology New York Routledge. pp. 108–118
Musicology’s applied foundations (Or, how music was musealised)
Zapletal, M. and Dromey, C. 2023. Musicology’s applied foundations (Or, how music was musealised). in: Dromey, C. (ed.) The Routledge Companion to Applied Musicology New York Routledge. pp. 23–33
Stravinsky’s ear for instruments
Dromey, C. 2020. Stravinsky’s ear for instruments. in: Griffiths, G. (ed.) Stravinsky in Context Cambridge University Press. pp. 170-178
New Horizons in Brazilian Contemporary Music: Grupo Novo Horizonte de São Paulo, 1988-99
Dromey, C. 2018. New Horizons in Brazilian Contemporary Music: Grupo Novo Horizonte de São Paulo, 1988-99. Tempo. 72 (284), pp. 52-67. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0040298217001267
On classical music competitions
Kwok, G. and Dromey, C. 2018. On classical music competitions. in: Dromey, C. and Haferkorn, J. (ed.) The Classical Music Industry Abingdon, Oxon Routledge. pp. 67-76
Arnold Schoenberg’s Pierrot lunaire: man, music, legacy
Dromey, C. 2016. Arnold Schoenberg’s Pierrot lunaire: man, music, legacy. 57th Little Missenden Festival: Post-interval talk. Little Missenden, United Kinkdom 07 - 10 Oct 2016
A century (and a bit) of Pierrot Ensembles: perspectives on Barcelona, London and São Paulo
Dromey, C. 2017. A century (and a bit) of Pierrot Ensembles: perspectives on Barcelona, London and São Paulo. Musical Modernism and the Commedia dell'arte. City, University of London, United Kingdom Jun 2017
Competitions: Classical and Popular
Dromey, C. 2014. Competitions: Classical and Popular. in: Thompson, W. (ed.) Music in the Social and Behavioral Sciences: An Encyclopedia Sage.
Hierarchical organization
Dromey, C. 2014. Hierarchical organization. in: Thompson, W. (ed.) Music in the Social and Behavioral Sciences: An Encyclopedia Sage.
Dorothy Dorow
Dromey, C. 2015. Dorothy Dorow. in: Grove Music Online (Oxford Music Online) Oxford University Press (OUP).
So You Want to Write An Opera?
Dromey, C. 2015. So You Want to Write An Opera? The Works: Magazine of the British Academy of Songwriters, Composers and Authors.
Prospects for a British 'Second Modernity' in the Music of Matthew Taylor and Peter Fribbins
Dromey, C. 2012. Prospects for a British 'Second Modernity' in the Music of Matthew Taylor and Peter Fribbins. New Music in Britain, organised by Dr Eva Mantzourani. Canterbury Christ Church University 10 - 12 May 2012
A Snapshot of the 'Pierrot' Ensemble Today
Dromey, C. 2013. A Snapshot of the 'Pierrot' Ensemble Today. Third International Meeting for Chamber Music, organised by Dr Zoltan Paulinyi. University of Évora, Portugal 08 - 10 Jan 2013
Pierrot ensemble
Dromey, C. 2015. Pierrot ensemble. in: Grove Music Online (Oxford Music Online) Oxford University Press (OUP).
The “Pierrot” Ensemble before the Pierrot Players
Dromey, C. 2006. The “Pierrot” Ensemble before the Pierrot Players. Schoenberg's Pierrot lunaire and Its Legacy. Kingston University 02 Mar 2006
Programme notes (2008 - present) for the London Chamber Music Society (LCMS), Kings Place, London
Dromey, C. 2016. Programme notes (2008 - present) for the London Chamber Music Society (LCMS), Kings Place, London. London Chamber Music Society.
The Pierrot Ensemble in Brazil: the music of Harry Crowl and Silvio Ferraz
Dromey, C. 2014. The Pierrot Ensemble in Brazil: the music of Harry Crowl and Silvio Ferraz. Fourth International Meeting for Chamber Music. University of Brasília, Brazil 12 Apr 2014
Talking about classical music: radio as public musicology
Dromey, C. 2018. Talking about classical music: radio as public musicology. in: Dromey, C. and Haferkorn, J. (ed.) The Classical Music Industry Abingdon, Oxon Routledge. pp. 183-261
Dances and Laments: Chamber Music by Peter Fribbins
Dromey, C. 2014. Dances and Laments: Chamber Music by Peter Fribbins. Guild.
Peter Fribbins: Chamber and Orchestral Works
Dromey, C. 2011. Peter Fribbins: Chamber and Orchestral Works. Guild.
Peter Fribbins: Chamber Music for Strings
Dromey, C. 2010. Peter Fribbins: Chamber Music for Strings. Guild.
The 'Pierrot' Ensemble in London: The Birth of a Genre?
Dromey, C. 2005. The 'Pierrot' Ensemble in London: The Birth of a Genre? Society for Music Analysis TAGS conference. University of East Anglia 23 Apr 2005
The Pierrot Ensembles, 1912-2012
Dromey, C. 2013. The Pierrot Ensembles, 1912-2012. Concerts and Colloquia series. Middlesex University 24 Jan 2013
Modernism(s) reborn? British chamber music in analysis
Dromey, C. 2014. Modernism(s) reborn? British chamber music in analysis. 16th Annual conference of the Modernist Studies Association (MSA 16): Confluence and Division. Pittsburgh, USA 06 - 09 Nov 2014
A Century of Pierrot Ensembles, 1912-2012
Dromey, C. 2013. A Century of Pierrot Ensembles, 1912-2012. Music Colloquia. King’s College London 16 Oct 2013
Benjamin Britten’s 'Pierrot' Ensembles
Dromey, C. 2010. Benjamin Britten’s 'Pierrot' Ensembles. in: Riley, M. (ed.) British Music and Modernism, 1895-1960 Farnham Ashgate. pp. 219-247
Prospects for Neomodernism in the Music of Matthew Taylor and Peter Fribbins
Dromey, C. 2013. Prospects for Neomodernism in the Music of Matthew Taylor and Peter Fribbins. International Journal for Contemporary Composition. 7, pp. 1-19.
Schoenberg, Zemlinsky, and the String Sextet
Dromey, C. 2006. Schoenberg, Zemlinsky, and the String Sextet. Zemlinsky Lost and Found, conference organised by Dr Mine Dogantan Dack, Dr Peter Fribbins and Dr Christopher Dromey. Middlesex University, London, UK 11 Oct 2006
Zemlinsky’s Surface Structures: Maiblumen blühten überall and the String Sextet Genre
Dromey, C. 2007. Zemlinsky’s Surface Structures: Maiblumen blühten überall and the String Sextet Genre. in: Frith, M. (ed.) Zemlinsky Studies Middlesex University Press. pp. 77-89
Three Pedagogic Innovations to Improve Learning on the BA Music and Arts Management Programme
Dromey, C., Anastasiades, M. and Yiangou, C. 2007. Three Pedagogic Innovations to Improve Learning on the BA Music and Arts Management Programme. Conference co-presented by the School of Health and Social Science and the Centre for Learning and Quality Enhancement (CLQE) “On Formative Assessment”. Middlesex University, London, UK 12 Nov 2007
The Pierrot Ensembles
Dromey, C. 2010. The Pierrot Ensembles. PhD thesis King's College, London Music
A Snapshot of the Pierrot Ensemble Today
Dromey, C. 2013. A Snapshot of the Pierrot Ensemble Today. Proceedings of the Third International Meeting for Chamber Music.
The Pierrot Ensembles: Chronicle and Catalogue, 1912-2012
Dromey, C. Wintle, C. (ed.) 2012. The Pierrot Ensembles: Chronicle and Catalogue, 1912-2012. London Plumbago.
Peter Maxwell Davies.
Dromey, C. 2008. Peter Maxwell Davies. in: Wintle, J. (ed.) New Makers of Modern Culture New York Routledge.