What cannot be said: speech and violence

Article

Siebers, J. 2010. What cannot be said: speech and violence. Journal of Global Ethics. 6 (2), pp. 89-102. https://doi.org/10.1080/17449626.2010.494356
TypeArticle
TitleWhat cannot be said: speech and violence
AuthorsSiebers, J.
Abstract

In this article, I consider the moment where speech becomes violent because it wants to name at any price – something that can be felt as a desire in speech, a tension of creation and destruction. I discuss Habermas' theory of communicative action and the propositional conception of truth that underpins it. That conception of truth can be contrasted to the theory of truth as event, as it has been developed by Alain Badiou. A similarity between Badiou's theory of truth and the latent utopianism of Adorno's negative dialectics shows that, for contemporary philosophy, the first phase of Frankfurt School theorising remains important. A philosophy that is able to ‘motivate and guide the will’ (Habermas) needs to include a non-propositional conception of truth; only with a non-propositional conception of truth can we articulate what is involved in communicative violence and come to understand what the place of what cannot be said is, in thought as well as in private, social and political life.

Research GroupLaw and Politics
PublisherTaylor and Francis
JournalJournal of Global Ethics
ISSN1744-9626
Publication dates
Print2010
Publication process dates
Deposited17 Feb 2014
Output statusPublished
Additional information

Special Issue: Critical theory and the language of violence.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1080/17449626.2010.494356
LanguageEnglish
Permalink -

https://repository.mdx.ac.uk/item/84q24

Log in to edit
  • 30
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 1
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

“I’ll show you differences”: Skills, creativity and meaning
Siebers, J. and Cobley, P. 2024. “I’ll show you differences”: Skills, creativity and meaning. Social Epistemology. 38 (1), pp. 28-37. https://doi.org/10.1080/02691728.2023.2283845
The Barnet Council Citizens’ Assembly on Climate Change and Biodiversity
Warren, G. and Siebers, J. 2023. The Barnet Council Citizens’ Assembly on Climate Change and Biodiversity. Middlesex University London.
Paying attention to time in communication research
Siebers, J. 2021. Paying attention to time in communication research. in: Facer, K., Siebers, J. and Smith, B. (ed.) Working with time in qualitative research: case studies, theory and practice London, UK Routledge.
Close reading and distance: between invariance and a rhetoric of embodiment
Cobley, P. and Siebers, J. 2021. Close reading and distance: between invariance and a rhetoric of embodiment. Language Sciences. 84, pp. 1-22. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.langsci.2021.101359
Ernst Bloch: Revue internationale de philosophie, 2019/3 (n° 289), ISSN 0048-8143
Siebers, J. Siebers, J. (ed.) 2019. Ernst Bloch: Revue internationale de philosophie, 2019/3 (n° 289), ISSN 0048-8143. De Boeck Supérieur.
Being as communication: an exploratory model
Siebers, J. 2019. Being as communication: an exploratory model. in: Bergman, M., Kirtiklis, K. and Siebers, J. (ed.) Models of communication: theoretical and philosophical approaches London Routledge. pp. 173-184
Transgression: introduction to the special issue on Ernst Bloch
Siebers, J. 2019. Transgression: introduction to the special issue on Ernst Bloch. Revue Internationale de Philosophie. 289 (3,2019), pp. 251-260. https://doi.org/10.3917/rip.289.0251
Philosophy as rhetoric
Siebers, J. 2019. Philosophy as rhetoric. Revue Internationale de Philosophie. 289 (3,2019), pp. 361-374. https://doi.org/10.3917/rip.289.0361
I interpret you: Davidson and Buber
Dresner, E. and Siebers, J. 2019. I interpret you: Davidson and Buber. The Review of Metaphysics. 73 (1), pp. 109-126.
Introduction
Bergman, M., Kirtiklis, K. and Siebers, J. 2019. Introduction. in: Bergman, M., Kirtiklis, K. and Siebers, J. (ed.) Models of communication: theoretical and philosophical approaches London Routledge. pp. 1-8
Editorial
Siebers, J. 2019. Editorial. Empedocles: European Journal for the Philosophy of Communication. 10 (1), pp. 3-5. https://doi.org/10.1386/ejpc.10.1.3_2
Exploring the impact of contemplative methods in HE learning and teaching
Siebers, J., Cullen, A., Guest, C., Kerin, L., Peyrefitte, M., Rodriguez, S. and Seoighe, R. 2018. Exploring the impact of contemplative methods in HE learning and teaching. Middlesex University Annual Learning and Teaching Conference 2018: Pedagogies Fit for 21st Century Learning. London, UK
Creativity and the ontology of not-yet being
Siebers, J. 2021. Creativity and the ontology of not-yet being. in: Kemp, S. and Anderson, J. (ed.) Futures Oxford, UK Oxford University Press (OUP). pp. 161-173
The theory of perfective drift
Siebers, J. 2017. The theory of perfective drift. in: Smith, A., Catt, I. and Klyukanov, I. (ed.) Communicology for the Human Sciences: Lanigan and the Philosophy of Communication Oxford Peter Lang. pp. 169-190
‘Die welt gut im gang': der Friedenstopos in Ernst Bloch’s philosophie
Siebers, J. 2016. ‘Die welt gut im gang': der Friedenstopos in Ernst Bloch’s philosophie. in: Vidal, F. and Wild, W. (ed.) Die Utopie des Friedens. Jahrbuch der Ernst-Bloch-Gesellschaft 2016/17 Wuerzburg Koenigshausen & Neumann.
Das merke des lesens: Blochs randbemerkungen zu Hegels phänomenologie des geistes
Siebers, J. 2017. Das merke des lesens: Blochs randbemerkungen zu Hegels phänomenologie des geistes. in: Kufeld, K. (ed.) Bloch Almanach Aisthesis Verlag.
Ernst Bloch's geist der utopie after a century: a Janus-Faced reading on the Trail of Hope
Siebers, J. 2018. Ernst Bloch's geist der utopie after a century: a Janus-Faced reading on the Trail of Hope. in: Silberman, M. (ed.) Back to the future: tradition and innovation in German studies Oxford Peter Lang.
The Dao of communication [Editorial]
Pablé, A. and Siebers, J. 2018. The Dao of communication [Editorial]. Empedocles: European Journal for the Philosophy of Communication. 9 (2), pp. 103-106. https://doi.org/10.1386/ejpc.9.2.103_2
Bij Shell werd ik de Marxist die ik nu ben
Siebers, J. and Akkerman, S. 2016. Bij Shell werd ik de Marxist die ik nu ben. Amsterdam Trouw.
Johan Siebers on Bloch, hope and Utopia
Siebers, J. and Barron, N. 2014. Johan Siebers on Bloch, hope and Utopia. Nyx, A Noctournal.
The Use of the Pen: A Philosophical Improvisation
Siebers, J. 2014. The Use of the Pen: A Philosophical Improvisation. Critical Muslim. 12, pp. 141-149.
"Die Welt gut im Gang": der Friedenstopos in Blochs Philosophie
Siebers, J. 2016. "Die Welt gut im Gang": der Friedenstopos in Blochs Philosophie. in: Vidal, F. and Wild, W. (ed.) Die Utopie des Friedens: Jahrbuch der Ernst Bloch Gesellschaft 2016/17 Würzburg Königshausen & Neumann. pp. 129-145
'Myth means: the saying word' / 'The Lord said that he would dwell in thick darkness'
Siebers, J. 2011. 'Myth means: the saying word' / 'The Lord said that he would dwell in thick darkness'. in: Hemming, L., Amiridis, K. and Costea, B. (ed.) The movement of Nihilism: Heidegger’s thinking after Nietzsche London Continuum. pp. 144-154
Community and future in the thought of Ernst Bloch
Siebers, J. 2012. Community and future in the thought of Ernst Bloch. in: Vidal, F. (ed.) Einblicke in Blochsche Philosophie Mössingen Talheimer Verlag.
An exploration of the relation between the concepts of 'community' and 'future' in philosophy
Siebers, J. and Fell, E. 2011. An exploration of the relation between the concepts of 'community' and 'future' in philosophy. Swindon, UK AHRC.
The time of the clock and the time of encounter
Siebers, J., Bastian, M., Douglas, A. and Speed, C. 2013. The time of the clock and the time of encounter. Swindon, UK AHRC.
Communicating wisdom: An Arts and Humanities-based study of fishing in youth work
Siebers, J., Pahl, K., Steadman-Jones, R., Pool, S., McMillan, A., Escott, H. and Hurcombe, M. 2015. Communicating wisdom: An Arts and Humanities-based study of fishing in youth work. Swindon, UK AHRC.
The utopian function of film music
Siebers, J. 2014. The utopian function of film music. in: Mazierska, E. and Kristensen, L. (ed.) Marx at the Movies: Revisiting History, Theory and Practice London Palgrave Macmillan UK. pp. 46-61
Authentic Passivity
Siebers, J. 2014. Authentic Passivity. in: Zeilinger, D. (ed.) VorSchein 32: Jahrbuch 2012/2013 der Ernst-Bloch-Assoziation Nürnberg, Germany Antogo. pp. 161-174
Some foundational conceptions of communication: revising and expanding the traditions of thought
Simonson, P., García-Jiménez, L., Siebers, J. and Craig, R. 2012. Some foundational conceptions of communication: revising and expanding the traditions of thought. Empedocles: European Journal for the Philosophy of Communication. 4 (1), pp. 73-92. https://doi.org/10.1386/ejpc.4.1.73_1
The destiny of metaphysics in Russia: an investigation of being and communicative behavior
Siebers, J. 2015. The destiny of metaphysics in Russia: an investigation of being and communicative behavior. Russian Journal of Communication. 7 (1), pp. 1-9. https://doi.org/10.1080/19409419.2015.1007556
ДИНАМИКА КОНСТРУИРОВАНИЯ ОБРАЗОВ БУДУЩЕГО: ИССЛЕДОВАНИЕ ПРОБЛЕМЫ
Lukianova, N., Fell, E. and Siebers, J. 2015. ДИНАМИКА КОНСТРУИРОВАНИЯ ОБРАЗОВ БУДУЩЕГО: ИССЛЕДОВАНИЕ ПРОБЛЕМЫ. Siberian Journal of Science. 2 (17), pp. 37-46.
The use of the pen: a philosophical improvisation
Siebers, J. 2014. The use of the pen: a philosophical improvisation. Critical Muslim. 12 (3), pp. 141-149.
Quietude and identity: the silent core of language
Siebers, J. 2012. Quietude and identity: the silent core of language. Empedocles: European Journal for the Philosophy of Communication. 4 (1). https://doi.org/10.1386/ejpc.4.1.3_1
Why drawing, now?
Douglas, A., Ravetz, A., Genever, K. and Siebers, J. 2014. Why drawing, now? Journal of Art & Communities. 6 (2-3), pp. 119-131. https://doi.org/10.1386/jaac.6.2-3.119_1
The fiery truth of matter
Siebers, J. 2014. The fiery truth of matter. Critical Muslim. 10 (3), pp. 143-152.
Aufenthalt im Unerhoerten : Bloch's reading of Hebel (1926-1965)
Siebers, J. 2011. Aufenthalt im Unerhoerten : Bloch's reading of Hebel (1926-1965). Oxford German Studies. 40 (1), pp. 62-71. https://doi.org/10.1179/007871911x568052
The method of speculative philosophy: an essay on the foundations of Whitehead's metaphysics.
Siebers, J. 1998. The method of speculative philosophy: an essay on the foundations of Whitehead's metaphysics. PhD thesis University of Leiden Philosophy
Ernst Bloch's dialectical anthropology
Siebers, J. 2013. Ernst Bloch's dialectical anthropology. in: Thompson, P. and Zizek, S. (ed.) The privatisation of hope: Ernst Bloch and the future of utopia Duke University Press.
The utopian horizon of communication: Ernst Bloch’s Traces and Johann-Peter Hebel’s Treasure Chest
Siebers, J. 2013. The utopian horizon of communication: Ernst Bloch’s Traces and Johann-Peter Hebel’s Treasure Chest. in: Sell, R., Borch, A. and Lindgren, I. (ed.) The ethics of literary communication: genuineness, directness, indirectness John Benjamins. pp. 189-212
The measure of the ultimate
Siebers, J. 2012. The measure of the ultimate. in: Herrmann-Sinai, S. and Tegtmeyer, H. (ed.) Metaphysik der Hoffnung: Ernst Bloch als Denker des Humanen Leipzig, Germany Leipzig University Press / Leipziger Universitätsverlag.