Michael and Gertrud: art and the artist in the films of Carl Theodor Dreyer

Book chapter


Heinemann, D. 2012. Michael and Gertrud: art and the artist in the films of Carl Theodor Dreyer. in: Allen, S. and Hubner, L. (ed.) Framing film: cinema and the visual arts Bristol, UK Intellect Books. pp. 149-164
Chapter titleMichael and Gertrud: art and the artist in the films of Carl Theodor Dreyer
AuthorsHeinemann, D.
Abstract

The films of Carl Theodor Dreyer are among the most painterly in cinema. Paintings and painting traditions are referenced throughout Dreyer’s work, and his scenographic space contains numerous paintings and objets d’art. These works play a decorative role, but also a narrative one: they presage and mirror events; they express or catalyse characters and relationships. While characters relate actively to these works of art, interpreting and communicating through them, the films’ narration frequently aestheticises the characters, transforming them into works of art in their own right. Through composition, staging and performance – Dreyer’s tableau style, close-ups of disembodied faces, statue-like poses – characters are compared, and compare themselves, to figures in art, even as they attempt to assert themselves within the diegesis. At once automaton and agent, the characters inhabit an uncertain realm between object and subject, predetermination and free will. From the conflict between these opposing orientations, often manifested through the forced marriage of narrative development and pictorial stasis, Dreyer reveals the dislocations of the human soul.
Dreyer’s concern with the narrative possibilities of painting is most evident in Michael (1924), a film about the relationship between two painters, and the director’s most sustained elaboration of his tableau style prior to Gertrud (1964), which it anticipates. Together the two films bookend the major works of Dreyer’s career, while remaining stubbornly on the fringes of greatness, their narrative and stylistic difficulties preventing a wholehearted embrace by most critics. Drawing on Bordwell’s magisterial study of Dreyer, the recent monograph on Gertrud by James Schamus, and notions of the automaton as explored by Deleuze in Cinema 2: The Time-Image, this paper examines the pictorial, narrative and thematic roles played by painting and objets d’art in the two films and situates the films within the context of Dreyer’s oeuvre, paying particular attention to their broader function within the director’s cinematic thought and practice.

LanguageEnglish
Page range149-164
Book titleFraming film: cinema and the visual arts
EditorsAllen, S. and Hubner, L.
PublisherIntellect Books
Place of publicationBristol, UK
ISBN
Hardcover9781841505077
Publication dates
PrintAug 2012
Publication process dates
Deposited08 Apr 2014
Output statusPublished
Accepted author manuscript
Web address (URL)http://www.intellectbooks.co.uk/books/view-Book,id=4854/
Permalink -

https://repository.mdx.ac.uk/item/84qw9

Download files

  • 26
    total views
  • 15
    total downloads
  • 4
    views this month
  • 3
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Voices apart
Heinemann, D., Nevardauskaite, E. and Broken Island Films 2020. Voices apart.
Remember, thou art clay
Heinemann, D., Nevardauskaite, E. and Broken Island Films 2017. Remember, thou art clay.
Unburied
Heinemann, D., Nevardauskaite, E. and Broken Island Films 2018. Unburied.
The French documentary in context: genealogy, aesthetics, ethics
Heinemann, D. and Tay, S. 2014. The French documentary in context: genealogy, aesthetics, ethics. Studies in French Cinema. 14 (3), pp. 157-166. https://doi.org/10.1080/14715880.2014.949452
Siren song: the narrating voice in two films by Raúl Ruiz
Heinemann, D. 2013. Siren song: the narrating voice in two films by Raúl Ruiz. Cinema Comparat/ive Cinema. 1 (3), pp. 66-75.
Whore
Heinemann, D., Vahey, S., Boulifa, F., Berliner, M., B3 Media and UK Film Council 2008. Whore.
Afternoon
Heinemann, D., Vahey, S., Boulifa, F., Ng, S., B3 Media and UK Film Council 2008. Afternoon.
The creative voice: free indirect speech in the cinema of Rohmer and Bresson
Heinemann, D. 2012. The creative voice: free indirect speech in the cinema of Rohmer and Bresson. Studies in French cinema: screen sounds. King's College, London 14 Apr 2008 Edinburgh University Press. https://doi.org/10.3366/sound.2012.0024