History of the special procedures: a ‘learning-by-doing’ approach to human rights implementation

Book chapter

Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2017. History of the special procedures: a ‘learning-by-doing’ approach to human rights implementation. in: Nolan, A., Freedman, R. and Murphy, T. (ed.) United Nations Special Procedures De Gruyter Brill.
Chapter titleHistory of the special procedures: a ‘learning-by-doing’ approach to human rights implementation
AuthorsDominguez-Redondo, E.
Abstract

The existence of UN Special Procedures is the unintended result of the competence accorded to the United Nations Commission on Human Rights and the Sub-Commission on the Prevention of Discrimination and Protection of Minorities in the 1967 Economic and Social Council Resolution 1235 (XLII). The Resolution authorised both bodies ‘to examine information relevant to gross violations of human rights and fundamental freedoms’. The lack of foresight in the creation of such mechanisms, now known as ‘special procedures’, is a fundamental factor in explaining the evolution of methods of work developed by different mandate holders. The ‘soft’ legal basis and geo-political factors surrounding the creation and renewal of mandates explains the freedom and flexibility they have enjoyed in establishing innovative monitoring activities that are more intrusive upon state sovereignty than any other UN human rights mechanism. As the significance of the Special Procedures’ work has grown, attempts to curtail their autonomy and impact have increased accordingly, facilitated precisely by what has been seen as, until recently, their major strength: the lack of a strong institutional and coherent legal framework regulating their activities. This chapter analyses this evolution and outlines the major challenges mandate holders face in maintaining their relevance.

Research GroupLaw and Politics
Book titleUnited Nations Special Procedures
EditorsNolan, A., Freedman, R. and Murphy, T.
PublisherDe Gruyter Brill
SeriesNottingham Studies on Human Rights
ISBN
Hardcover9789004304697
Publication dates
Print09 Jan 2017
Publication process dates
Deposited12 Oct 2015
Accepted12 Sep 2015
Output statusPublished
Accepted author manuscript
Copyright Statement

This is an Accepted Manuscript of an chapter published by Brill in the book United Nations Special Procedures. Reproduced in this repository with permission https://brill.com/page/RightsPermissions/rights-and-permissions#self...

Additional information

E-ISBN: 9789004304703

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004304703_003
LanguageEnglish
Permalink -

https://repository.mdx.ac.uk/item/85z0y

Log in to edit

Download files

Accepted author manuscript
History_of_the_Special_Procedures_A_Lear-2 copy.pdf

  • 61
    total views
  • 100
    total downloads
  • 7
    views this month
  • 2
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Russian misuse of international law is final nail in coffin of post WW2 order [Blog post]
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2022. Russian misuse of international law is final nail in coffin of post WW2 order [Blog post]. IntLawGrrls.
The Existence and Efficacy of Affirmative Action Measures in UK, South Africa, India, China, Latin America & Brazil
Baéz, N. and Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2018. The Existence and Efficacy of Affirmative Action Measures in UK, South Africa, India, China, Latin America & Brazil. Jaocaba, Brazil Editora Unoesc.
Introduction
Dominguez-Redondo, E. and Howard, E. 2020. Introduction. in: Howard, E., Dominguez-Redondo, E. and Baéz, N. (ed.) Affirmative Action and the Law: Efficacy of National and International Approaches London / New York Routledge. pp. 3-12
Universalism or fragmentation: United Nations treaty-bodies and affirmative actions in Latin-America, the United Kingdom, South Africa, China and India
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2020. Universalism or fragmentation: United Nations treaty-bodies and affirmative actions in Latin-America, the United Kingdom, South Africa, China and India. in: Howard, E., Dominguez-Redondo, E. and Baéz, N. (ed.) Affirmative Action and the Law: Efficacy of National and International Approaches London / New York Routledge. pp. 13-35
Contextualizing the Cassese Report: the dictatorship that changed the United Nations human rights system and its legacy in monitoring economic, social and cultural rights
Dominguez-Redondo, E. and Sepulveda Carmona, M. 2021. Contextualizing the Cassese Report: the dictatorship that changed the United Nations human rights system and its legacy in monitoring economic, social and cultural rights. in: Bohoslavsky, J., Fernández, K. and Smart, S. (ed.) Pinochet's Economic Accomplices: An Unequal Country by Force London Lexington Books. pp. 63-76
Lagunas (intencionadas) del derecho internacional en la delimitación de obligaciones del Estado
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2020. Lagunas (intencionadas) del derecho internacional en la delimitación de obligaciones del Estado. in: Bohoslavsky, J. (ed.) Covid-19 y derechos humanos: la pandemia de la desigualdad Buenos Aires, Argentina Editorial Biblos. pp. 77-92
In defence of politicization of human rights: the UN special procedures
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2020. In defence of politicization of human rights: the UN special procedures. Oxford University Press (OUP).
Contextualizando el Informe Cassese: La dictadura que cambió el sistema de derechos humanos de Naciones Unidas y su legado en el monitoreo de derechos económicos, sociales y culturales
Dominguez-Redondo, E. and Sepulveda Carmona, M. 2019. Contextualizando el Informe Cassese: La dictadura que cambió el sistema de derechos humanos de Naciones Unidas y su legado en el monitoreo de derechos económicos, sociales y culturales. in: Bohoslavsky, J., Fernandez, K. and Smart, S. (ed.) Complicidad económica con la dictadura chilena: Un país desigual a la fuerza LOM ediciones. pp. 97-107
Reform of the UN human rights petitions system: an assessment of the UN human rights communications procedures and proposals for a single integrated system
Limon, M., Dominguez-Redondo, E., Power, H., Stahl-Zulu, I. and Munoz Tord, N. 2017. Reform of the UN human rights petitions system: an assessment of the UN human rights communications procedures and proposals for a single integrated system. Universal Rights Group.
The Assange saga: who does the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention represent?
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2016. The Assange saga: who does the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention represent? IntLawGrrls.
UK’s lost seat at the International Court of Justice: a reflection on the authority of the Security Council [Blog post]
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2017. UK’s lost seat at the International Court of Justice: a reflection on the authority of the Security Council [Blog post]. IntLawGrrls.
Have your cake and eat it too: the impossible stance on the Syrian strike
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2018. Have your cake and eat it too: the impossible stance on the Syrian strike. IntLawGrrls.
El sistema universal de protección de derechos humanos
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2017. El sistema universal de protección de derechos humanos. in: Marino Menendez, F., Perez Gonzalez, C. and Cebada Romero, A. (ed.) Instrumentos y regímenes de cooperación internacionales Editorial Trotta. pp. 19-39
La crisis de los derechos humanos: necesidad de un cambio de estrategia [Confidence crisis in human rights: the need of rethinking strategies]
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2017. La crisis de los derechos humanos: necesidad de un cambio de estrategia [Confidence crisis in human rights: the need of rethinking strategies]. Revista ESMAT. 9 (14), pp. 103-114.
The United Nations approach to temporary special measures
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2018. The United Nations approach to temporary special measures. in: Baéz, N. and Dominguez-Redondo, E. (ed.) The Existence and Efficacy of Affirmative Action Measures in UK, South Africa, India, China, Latin America & Brazil Jaocaba, Brazil Editora Unoesc. pp. 239-269
Guest post: General Court of the European Union annuls the EU-Morocco Free Trade Agreement on human rights grounds but forgets self-determination
Bernaz, N. and Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2015. Guest post: General Court of the European Union annuls the EU-Morocco Free Trade Agreement on human rights grounds but forgets self-determination. Opinio Juris.
Human rights through the backdoor: the contribution of special procedures to the normative coherence and contradictions of International Human Rights Law
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2016. Human rights through the backdoor: the contribution of special procedures to the normative coherence and contradictions of International Human Rights Law. in: Buckley, C., Donald, A. and Leach, P. (ed.) Towards Convergence in International Human Rights Law: Approaches of Regional and International Systems De Gruyter Brill.
In defense of life: Civil Observation Mission (MOC) report on the situation of human rights defenders in Mexico 2015 = En defensa de la vida: conclusiones de la Misión de Observación Civil sobre la situación de las personas defensoras en México 2015
Baeyens Caro, A., Openshaw, E., Dominguez-Redondo, E., Figari Layús, R. and Comisión Mexicana de Defensa y Promoción de los Derechos Humanos, a.c. 2015. In defense of life: Civil Observation Mission (MOC) report on the situation of human rights defenders in Mexico 2015 = En defensa de la vida: conclusiones de la Misión de Observación Civil sobre la situación de las personas defensoras en México 2015. Mexico Comision Mexicana para la Promocion y Proteccion de los Derechos Humanos.
More honey than vinegar: peer review as a middle ground between universalism and national sovereignty
Dominguez-Redondo, E. and Mcmahon, E. 2015. More honey than vinegar: peer review as a middle ground between universalism and national sovereignty. Canadian Yearbook of International Law. 51, pp. 61-97. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0069005800011061
The title to Dokdo/Takeshima: addressing the legacy of World War II territorial settlements/finding the right settlement of dispute mechanism
Castellino, J. and Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2015. The title to Dokdo/Takeshima: addressing the legacy of World War II territorial settlements/finding the right settlement of dispute mechanism. International Journal on Minority and Group Rights. 22 (4), pp. 550-577. https://doi.org/10.1163/15718115-02204006
The identity question: who are the Sahrawis and what is their ‘home’?
Castellino, J. and Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2013. The identity question: who are the Sahrawis and what is their ‘home’? in: Boukhars, A. and Roussellier, J. (ed.) Perspectives on Western Sahara: myths, nationalisms, and geopolitics Rowman & Littlefield. pp. 29-54
The Universal Periodic Review - is there life beyond naming and shaming in human rights implementation?
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2012. The Universal Periodic Review - is there life beyond naming and shaming in human rights implementation? New Zealand Law Review. 2012 (4), pp. 673-706.
Los procedimientos públicos espciales de la Comision de Derechos Humanos de Naciones Unidas (Public Special Procedures of the UN Commission on Humna Rights)
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2005. Los procedimientos públicos espciales de la Comision de Derechos Humanos de Naciones Unidas (Public Special Procedures of the UN Commission on Humna Rights). Valencia Tirant lo Blanch.
Making the connection: security and human rights
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2011. Making the connection: security and human rights. in: Bassiouni, M. and Schabas, W. (ed.) New challenges for the UN Human Rights machinery: what future for the UN Treaty Body System and the Human Rights Council Procedures? Intersentia Publishers. pp. 255-277
Rethinking the legal foundations of control in international human rights law - the case of special procedures
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2011. Rethinking the legal foundations of control in international human rights law - the case of special procedures. Netherlands Quarterly of Human Rights. 29 (3).
UN public special procedures under Damocles' Sword - two particular innovations: mechanisms for the appointment of mandate-holders, and the adoption of a code of conduct for special procedures mandate-holders of the Human Rights Council.
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2008. UN public special procedures under Damocles' Sword - two particular innovations: mechanisms for the appointment of mandate-holders, and the adoption of a code of conduct for special procedures mandate-holders of the Human Rights Council. Human Rights Law Journal. 29 (1-5), pp. 32-40.
The EU, torture secrets and dealing with the truth.
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2009. The EU, torture secrets and dealing with the truth. Paris European Union Institute for security studies.
Role of the UN in the promotion and protection of human rights.
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2010. Role of the UN in the promotion and protection of human rights. in: Chowdhury, A. and Bhuiyan, J. (ed.) An introduction to international human rights law. Leiden, Nethelands De Gruyter Brill.
An overview of human rights instruments to raise concerns about trade and investment polices.
Dominguez-Redondo, E. and Carmona, M. 2009. An overview of human rights instruments to raise concerns about trade and investment polices. in: Murphy, S. and Paasch, A. (ed.) The global food challenge: towards a human rights approach to trade and investment policies Bern Brot fur alle [Bread for all]. pp. 92-101
The prevention of torture: complaints mechanism, investigation and prosecution of alleged perpetrators.
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2003. The prevention of torture: complaints mechanism, investigation and prosecution of alleged perpetrators. in: Chinese Yearbook of Human Rights Chinese Academy of Social Sciences.
The Millennium Development Goals and the human rights based approach: reflecting on structural chasms with the United Nations system.
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2009. The Millennium Development Goals and the human rights based approach: reflecting on structural chasms with the United Nations system. The International Journal of Human Rights. 13 (1), pp. 29-43. https://doi.org/10.1080/13642980802532317
The Universal Periodic Review of the UN Human Rights Council: an assessment of the first session
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2008. The Universal Periodic Review of the UN Human Rights Council: an assessment of the first session. Chinese Journal of International Law.. 7 (3), pp. 721-734. https://doi.org/10.1093/chinesejil/jmn029
Debe desaparecer la Comisión de Derechos Humanos de Naciones Unidas?
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2007. Debe desaparecer la Comisión de Derechos Humanos de Naciones Unidas? in: Beneyto, J. and Atienza, B. (ed.) Una nueva organización de Naciones Unidas para el siglo XXI. Madrid Biblioteca Nueva. pp. 109-143
La comisión de derechos humanos a debate: el procedimiento 1503.
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2006. La comisión de derechos humanos a debate: el procedimiento 1503. Revista iberoamericana de derechos humanos.. 2, pp. 34-80.
Los procedimientos públicos especiales de la Comisión de Derechos Humanos de Naciones Unidas y las nuevas dimensiones de la actividad del Consejo de Seguridad en el mantenimiento de la paz y seguridad internacional.
Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2001. Los procedimientos públicos especiales de la Comisión de Derechos Humanos de Naciones Unidas y las nuevas dimensiones de la actividad del Consejo de Seguridad en el mantenimiento de la paz y seguridad internacional. Revista electrónica de estudios internacionales. 2.
Minority rights in Asia: a comparative legal analysis
Castellino, J. and Dominguez-Redondo, E. 2006. Minority rights in Asia: a comparative legal analysis. Oxford Oxford University Press (OUP).
Minority rights in China: a legal overview.
Castellino, J., Dominguez-Redondo, E. and European Centre for Minority Issues 2006. Minority rights in China: a legal overview. in: European Yearbook of Minority Issues Martinus Nijhoff.