The road to Prest v Petrodel: an analysis of the UK judicial approach to The Corporate Veil - part 1

Article


Watkins, L. and Nsubuga, H. 2020. The road to Prest v Petrodel: an analysis of the UK judicial approach to The Corporate Veil - part 1. International company and commercial law review. 31 (10), pp. 547-588.
TypeArticle
TitleThe road to Prest v Petrodel: an analysis of the UK judicial approach to The Corporate Veil - part 1
AuthorsWatkins, L. and Nsubuga, H.
Abstract

This article examines the common law approach to the doctrine of separate legal personality in UK Corporate Law, its origin, development and the challenges encountered by judges in the interpretation and application of this doctrine. The article also analyses the grounds/circumstances upon which this doctrine may be disregarded by the judges to ‘lift/pierce’ the corporate veil. The article then analyses the judicial interpretative approaches to dichotomies and metaphors, such as ‘concealment/evasion’ and ‘shame/façade’ et cetera. The conclusion explores whether the UKSC decision in Prest v Petrodel Resources Ltd has, indeed, provided much needed clarity in the common law approach to the corporate veil.

PublisherSweet and Maxwell
JournalInternational company and commercial law review
ISSN0958-5214
Publication dates
Online14 Sep 2020
Print14 Sep 2020
Publication process dates
Deposited05 Aug 2020
Accepted23 May 2020
Output statusPublished
Accepted author manuscript
License
Copyright Statement

This is a pre-copyedited, author-produced version of an article accepted for publication in International company and commercial law review following peer review. The definitive published version Los Watkins and Hamiisi Junior Nsubuga, I.C.C.L.R. 2020, 31(10), 547-558 is available online on Westlaw UK. An Attribution-NonCommercial CC BY-NC use license applies to this manuscript version.

Web address (URL)https://uk.westlaw.com/Document/I0CA866F0F6E811EAADCEF1E1044A6484/View/FullText.html
LanguageEnglish
Permalink -

https://repository.mdx.ac.uk/item/89083

Download files

  • 248
    total views
  • 538
    total downloads
  • 27
    views this month
  • 59
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Fifteen years of the statutory derivative regime under the Companies Act 2006: a reflection on an unfulfilled superfluous statutory regime
Nsubuga, H. 2023. Fifteen years of the statutory derivative regime under the Companies Act 2006: a reflection on an unfulfilled superfluous statutory regime. Contemporary Issues in Law. 15 (1), pp. 63-82.
Enhancing depositor protection in the mobile money banking sector in sub-Saharan African developing economies – a case for ring-fencing?
Nsubuga, H. 2023. Enhancing depositor protection in the mobile money banking sector in sub-Saharan African developing economies – a case for ring-fencing? Journal of International Banking Law and Regulation. 38 (1), pp. 1-9.
Unravelling the mystery behind bank insolvencies in the East African Community (EAC) – the case for Uganda, Kenya and Tanzania
Nsubuga, H. 2022. Unravelling the mystery behind bank insolvencies in the East African Community (EAC) – the case for Uganda, Kenya and Tanzania. in: Akintola, K. and Adeyemo, F. (ed.) Bank Insolvency Law in Developing Economies London, UK Taylor & Francis (Routledge).
Local public entities in distress - an analysis of the Ugandan approach
Nsubuga, H. 2022. Local public entities in distress - an analysis of the Ugandan approach. in: Coordes, L., Vaccari, E. and Marique, Y. (ed.) When Liquidation is NOT an Option – A Global Study on Local Public Entities in Financial Distress INSOL International. pp. 347-361
Reinvigorating corporate rescue in developing economies – a Ugandan perspective
Nsubuga, H. 2021. Reinvigorating corporate rescue in developing economies – a Ugandan perspective. Insolvency Intelligence. 34 (4), pp. 95-102.
The debtor-in-possession model in the EU insolvency and restructuring framework - a domino effect?
Nsubuga, H. 2022. The debtor-in-possession model in the EU insolvency and restructuring framework - a domino effect? Journal of Business Law.
A reconsideration of directors’ liability for wrongful trading in the UK and the EU in the COVID19 era
Nsubuga, H. 2021. A reconsideration of directors’ liability for wrongful trading in the UK and the EU in the COVID19 era. in: A Collection of Short Papers by INSOL Early Research Academics (INSOL ERA) INSOL International. pp. 128-138
The road to Prest v Petrodel: an analysis of the UK judicial approach to the corporate veil - part 2: post Prest
Nsubuga, H. and Watkins, L. 2020. The road to Prest v Petrodel: an analysis of the UK judicial approach to the corporate veil - part 2: post Prest. International company and commercial law review. 31 (11), pp. 597-608.
Where did the floating charge come from? [Blog post]
Watkins, L. 2020. Where did the floating charge come from? [Blog post]. MDX Minds Middlesex University.
Women on corporate boards of public listed companies - a UK and EU gender diversity conundrum
Nsubuga, H. 2020. Women on corporate boards of public listed companies - a UK and EU gender diversity conundrum. in: Howard, E., Dominguez-Redondo, E. and Baéz, N. (ed.) Affirmative Action and the Law: Efficacy of National and International Approaches London and New York Routledge. pp. 163-178
The role of the central bank in financial distress management and resolution in developing economies
Nsubuga, H. 2020. The role of the central bank in financial distress management and resolution in developing economies. Journal of International Banking Law and Regulation. 35 (5), pp. 208-214.
The call for harmonisation of cross-border insolvency laws to enable cross-border filing and litigation in the East African community
Nsubuga, H. 2019. The call for harmonisation of cross-border insolvency laws to enable cross-border filing and litigation in the East African community. International company and commercial law review. 30 (12), pp. 659-668.
Employee rights in corporate insolvency: a UK and US perspective
Nsubuga, H. 2019. Employee rights in corporate insolvency: a UK and US perspective. London and New York Routledge.
The impact of bank insolvency on consumer protection and the drive towards the 2030 sustainable development agenda in developing economies: A Ugandan perspective
Nsubuga, H. 2019. The impact of bank insolvency on consumer protection and the drive towards the 2030 sustainable development agenda in developing economies: A Ugandan perspective. Rule of Law in the 2030 SDGs Agenda. Loyola University Chicago, John Felice Centre, Rome Italy 01 - 02 Feb 2019
Economic and social perspectives of corporate insolvency law in Uganda: The recent collapse of Crane Bank (Uganda) and the response to the 2007-2008 global economic crisis
Nsubuga, H. 2019. Economic and social perspectives of corporate insolvency law in Uganda: The recent collapse of Crane Bank (Uganda) and the response to the 2007-2008 global economic crisis. International Conference on Insolvency and Bankruptcy Laws - A Global Response. ICFAI Law School, Hyderabad, India - Organised by Widener University Delaware Law School and Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India 01 - 03 Mar 2019 ICFAI Foundation for Higher Education (IFHE). pp. 302-310
Towards a tort of political negligence: Political deceit, political misrepresentation and the Brexit conundrum
Nsubuga, H. 2019. Towards a tort of political negligence: Political deceit, political misrepresentation and the Brexit conundrum. An International Law Blog.
The rights of employees on corporate insolvency: a UK and US perspective
Nsubuga, H. 2018. The rights of employees on corporate insolvency: a UK and US perspective. PhD thesis Nottingham Law School, Nottingham Trent University School of Law
Corporate insolvency and employment protection: a theoretical perspective
Nsubuga, H. 2016. Corporate insolvency and employment protection: a theoretical perspective. Nottingham Insolvency and Business Law e-Journal. 4 (1).
Puzzling law [Blog post]
Watkins, L. 2018. Puzzling law [Blog post]. MDX Minds Middlesex University.
The fate of employment protection provisions under TUPE regulations post-Brexit
Nsubuga, H. 2018. The fate of employment protection provisions under TUPE regulations post-Brexit. The Academic Forum Annual Conference, INSOL EUROPE. Warsaw, Poland 04 - 05 Oct 2017
The interpretative approach to bankruptcy law: remedying the theoretical limitations in the traditionalist and the proceduralist perspectives on corporate insolvency
Nsubuga, H. 2018. The interpretative approach to bankruptcy law: remedying the theoretical limitations in the traditionalist and the proceduralist perspectives on corporate insolvency. International Journal of Law and Management. 60 (3), pp. 824-841. https://doi.org/10.1108/IJLMA-03-2017-0079