An investigation into the prevalence of Musculoskeletal Disorders (MSDS) within trades’ in high rise property development and the effects of age

Conference item


Thomas, D. 2019. An investigation into the prevalence of Musculoskeletal Disorders (MSDS) within trades’ in high rise property development and the effects of age. APOSHO 34 Conference. Guiyang (Guizhou) PRC 06 - 07 Sep 2019
TitleAn investigation into the prevalence of Musculoskeletal Disorders (MSDS) within trades’ in high rise property development and the effects of age
AuthorsThomas, D.
Abstract

Background
The term musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs) covers any injury, damage or disorder of the joints or other tissues in the upper/lower limbs or the back (HSE 2019) Wang (2017) stated that the rate of Workplace MSDs in construction remained higher than in all industries combined; the median days away from work increased from 8 days in 1992 to 13 days in 2014 and that construction workers continue to face a higher risk of MSDs. In the UK the HSE (HSE 2018) have identified a prevalence rate of 2310/100000 workers and 2410/100000 who are skilled trade workers with 469,000 Workers suffering from work-related musculoskeletal disorders (new or long-standing) in 2017/18. The loss of 6.6 million days accounts for 24% of all working days lost due to work-related ill health in the UK.
The Arthritis and Musculoskeletal Alliance (ARMA 2019) state that the physically demanding work
Helps contribute to the annual cost within the sector of £646m per year. With the UK removing the statutory retirement age, this creates health and safety challenges for older workers and those for whom they work (Barrett &Sargeant 2015).
Okunribido & Wynn (2010) state that age is not an independent risk factor for work-related MSD. Older workers are more susceptible to work-related MSD than younger workers because of decreased functional capacity. Bridger (2008) reports that by the age of 6 the male spinal compression tolerance limit has reduced by 63%.
Within the built environment in the UK there has been a change in construction methods required to support the increase in high rise, often for residential buildings. This change includes more modular work such as the installation of pre fitted kitchens and bathroom requiring dry lining and less traditional skills such as plastering, bricklaying and joinery.
With the aim to create a process to help create a sustainable workforce it is best to be able to intervene before a period of absence initially occurs. This means having the tools and a process being able to monitor and engage with the workforce.
Method – A small ‘task and finish’ project between one of the UKs largest construction contractors and the University of Greenwich was set up. This study considered also trades required in modern modular techniques rather than previous work based upon traditional trades as well as age. We also identified the most prevalent languages on site and translated the questionnaire into 5 other languages to improve worker engagement.
Following meetings with the group Director for Health, Safety and Wellbeing contacts with a suitable site were made. Following a discussion with local management the specific work groups were identified together with the languages spoken on site. It was agreed to use body mapping Thomas et.al. (2018) on an individual basis – looking for specific tingling in fingers that could be associated with hand tools, pain that would go away after a period of rest and persistent pain
If workers in a particular job pool share health problems then patterns may emerge using bodymapping that are task related (Hazards, 1998) suggesting that it can
• Establish suitability of the individual to work
• Be an aid to the risk assessment process.
• Prioritize and support ergonomic improvements
• Compare ill health from different work groups
Keith and Brophy (2004) suggest that using this technique, together with statistical analysis, it is possible to identify and support associations and establish causal links. Findings can be compared with the literature available and together can be used until hazards are managed to an acceptable level (Mujica, 1992).
This was supplemented with questions around age, experience, role and recent absence associated with MSDs. This was agreed in advance and included assurances regarding data protection provisions. The contractor made contract with sub-contractors and it was agreed to provide feedback to sub-contractors to feedback to the workforce.
Staff completed surveys on site on 5 days between the 29th April and 8th May 2019. Researchers were escorted around site by a member of the Primary Contractors ‘Contract Management Team. This was to help enable the researchers to find staff and to ensure researcher safety on site. Approximately 600 people were on site, the survey was looking for 40% participation from the workforce.
Groups were spoken to whilst in the second half of their shift.
Results
In total 202 staff participated in the survey, around a dozen staff refused and two who participated would not divulge their age. 199 were male and 3 were female. The survey identified 10 nationalities were identified, 24 Trades and Jobs and 41 companies/sub-contractors. Aside from the employees of the main contractor the majority of the remaining staff considered themselves self employed.
We were unable to obtain both Polish and Russian translations in time for the survey. Of the 202 participants 134 reported that they had pain at that time (66%). The average age was 39 with the lowest age 17 and highest 71. The average length of service in the construction sector was 13.3 years.
27 respondents were supervisors/management with 48% indicating current self-reported pain. 175 were operators with 69% indicating self-reported pain.97 respondents were native English speakers with 70 (72%) reporting self-reported pain. 69 respondents were Rumanian with 67% reporting they were experiencing pain . 12 respondents were Bulgarian with 75% reporting they were experiencing pain. Strangely 19 non English respondents (Ukrainian, Russian speaking Latvians and Poles) only 37% indicated they were experiencing pain.
When considering self-reported pain within different trades , 71% of dry liners/labourers were experiencing pain. 70% of Ground workers/Landscapers were experiencing pain, 52% of plumbers were experiencing pain and 100% of Electricians and general labourers are experiencing pain.
It was noted that amongst the non UK native staff that some nationalities were uncomfortable taking part until their ‘team leader’ had taken part or was happy with the results.
Responses for individual body map charts were transposed on to both activity and age related sheets to compare the different effects of MSDs between cohorts. This work is expected to be completed by the 31st July together with full findings, discussion and recommendations.
References
Arma, 2019, Musculoskeletal Conditions in the Construction Industry -Report of Roundtable 25 February 2019 - Arthritis and Musculoskeletal Alliance, online. Available at http://arma.uk.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/Construction-Roundtabl... Accessed 31/05/19
Barrett, B. and Sargeant, M., 2015. Working in the UK without a default retirement age: health, safety, and the oldest workers. Industrial law journal, 44(1), pp.75-100.
Bridger, R., 2008. Introduction to ergonomics. Crc Press.
Hazards. (1998). Body of evidence-Body mapping can unearth the health hazards in your workplace. Hazards 61 January–March 1998 (online). Available from www.hazards.org/diyresearch/bodymapping.pdf (Accessed 15 March 2012).
HSE, 2019, Musculoskeletal disorders, online Available at https://www.hse.gov.uk/MSD/, Accessed 31.05.19.
HSE 2018 Work related musculoskeletal disorders in Great Britain (WRMSDs) 2018, ,online. Available at https://www.hse.gov.uk/statistics/causdis/msd.pdf., Accessed 31/05/19
Keith, M.M., & Brophy, J.T. (2004). Participatory mapping of occupational hazards and disease among asbestos-exposed workers from a foundry and insulation complex in Canada. International Journal of Occupational and Environmental Health, 10(2), 144–153.
Mujica, J. (1992). Coloring the hazards: Risk maps research and education to fight health hazards. American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 22(5), 767–770.
Okunribido, O., & Wynn, T (2010) Ageing and work-related Musculoskeletal disorders, online, Available at https://www.hse.gov.uk/research/rrpdf/rr799.pdf Accessed 27/01/18
Thomas, D., Hare, B. and Cameron, I., 2018. Using body mapping as part of the risk assessment process–a case study. Policy and Practice in Health and Safety, 16(2), pp.224-240.
Wang, 2017, Work-related musculoskeletal disorders among construction workers in the United States from 1992 to 2014 online, Available at https://oem.bmj.com/content/74/5/374 Accessed

Sustainable Development Goals3 Good health and well-being
8 Decent work and economic growth
11 Sustainable cities and communities
Middlesex University ThemeSustainability
Health & Wellbeing
Research GroupEmployment Relations group
LanguageEnglish
ConferenceAPOSHO 34 Conference
Publication dates
Print06 Sep 2019
Publication process dates
Deposited04 Oct 2022
Accepted31 May 2019
Output statusPublished
Permalink -

https://repository.mdx.ac.uk/item/8q0x2

Restricted files

File

  • 34
    total views
  • 1
    total downloads
  • 3
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Complacency in fire evacuation from buildings: A technical research report into evacuee complacency, an overlooked component of fire safety management, from the IOSH Fire Risk Management Group
Gold, D., Thomas, D., Vincer, N. and Pitkin, M. 2023. Complacency in fire evacuation from buildings: A technical research report into evacuee complacency, an overlooked component of fire safety management, from the IOSH Fire Risk Management Group. LinkedIn.
Development of the LAWS Forum for Local Authorities (10 year journey!)
Thomas, D. 2019. Development of the LAWS Forum for Local Authorities (10 year journey!). Hampshire CASH Forum of Local Authorities. INTECH (Winchester Science Centre) 03 Sep 2014
MSD and approaches to management
Thomas, D. and Aptowitzer, S. 2012. MSD and approaches to management. IOSH Conference. Manchester Conference Centre 08 - 09 Mar 2012
Safety ownership
Thomas, D. 2021. Safety ownership. LinkedIn.
Relationships between Waste Collection Systems and MSD’s
Thomas, D. 2013. Relationships between Waste Collection Systems and MSD’s. LARAC Conference 2013 - The Annual Forum for Waste and Recycling Officers. East Midlands Conference Centre, Nottingham 16 - 17 Oct 2013
Prioritising Health and Safety- Soundbite-
Thomas, D. 2016. Prioritising Health and Safety- Soundbite-. The Loop.
The business case for human sustainability
Thomas, D. 2019. The business case for human sustainability. The 4th International Symposium on Business Cooperation and Development in South-East and South Asia under B&R Initiative. International Business School, Yunnan University of Finance & Economics, ChinaKunming , PRC 24 Nov 2019
Corporate psychopaths - included in your risk assessment processes?
Thomas, D. 2020. Corporate psychopaths - included in your risk assessment processes? Wellbeing Joint event with the Yorkshire Branch. On Line - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OCIzNlXxM2k&feature=youtu.be 16 Sep 2020
The effects of outsourcing work activity and use of agency staff on ill health absence: the case of local authority waste collection services (in the UK)
Thomas, D. 2022. The effects of outsourcing work activity and use of agency staff on ill health absence: the case of local authority waste collection services (in the UK). Ergonomics and Hygiene 2022 - https://conference.ieh.sg/about. The Fullerton Hotel Singapore 31 Aug - 01 Sep 2022
Examining the role of the occupational safety and health professional in supporting the control of the risks of multiple psychosocial stressors generated during the COVID-19 pandemic
Gold, D., Sharman, A. and Thomas, D. 2022. Examining the role of the occupational safety and health professional in supporting the control of the risks of multiple psychosocial stressors generated during the COVID-19 pandemic. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications. 9 (1), pp. 1-14. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-022-01079-7
A comparison of manual handling risks in different domestic waste collection systems using three separate evaluation methods
Thomas, D., Hare, B. and Evangelinos, K. 2021. A comparison of manual handling risks in different domestic waste collection systems using three separate evaluation methods. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics. 83, pp. 1-13. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ergon.2021.103111
Applying safety investigation standards to occupational health incidents
Thomas, D., Volmink, O., Donnelly, S., Rifá, M. and Michell, K. 2022. Applying safety investigation standards to occupational health incidents. ICOH/IOSH webinar. Online (London) 29 Sep 2022
Perceptions, experiences and opportunities for occupational safety and health professionals arising out of the COVID-19 Pandemic
Gold, D., Hughes, S. and Thomas, D. 2021. Perceptions, experiences and opportunities for occupational safety and health professionals arising out of the COVID-19 Pandemic. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications. 8 (1), pp. 1-14. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-021-00955-y
Resource and recycling – collaborative working and the EWMG
Thomas, D. 2020. Resource and recycling – collaborative working and the EWMG. Resource and Recycling: Midshires Branch and EWMG. Online - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LTtLmEQkZGU 12 Nov 2020
The identification of the domestic waste collection system associated with the least operative musculoskeletal disorders using human resource absence data
Thomas, D., Mulville, M. and Hare, B. 2019. The identification of the domestic waste collection system associated with the least operative musculoskeletal disorders using human resource absence data. Resources, Conservation and Recycling. 150, pp. 1-14. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2019.104424
Can HR and H&S work together to bring about sustainable rehabilitation?
Thomas, D., Corby, S. and Tsay, C. 2018. Can HR and H&S work together to bring about sustainable rehabilitation? 33rd Asia Pacific Occupational Safety and Health Organization annual conference (APOSHO 33). Regal Kowloon Hotel, Hong Kong 04 - 05 Dec 2018 APOSHO/IOSH.
What do we mean by “Wellbeing”?
Thomas, D. 2018. What do we mean by “Wellbeing”? Hong Kong SPACE Open Conference. Admiralty Campus, Hong Kong 03 Dec 2018
Independent review of building regulations and fire safety: next steps
Thomas, D. 2018. Independent review of building regulations and fire safety: next steps. Building Maintenance Advisory Group - (Southern region). London Borough of Tower Hamlets 19 Oct 2017
Enhancing health and safety in the workplace
Thomas, D. 2017. Enhancing health and safety in the workplace. Enhancing Health and Safety in the Workplace - "Inside Government". Congress Centre, London 24 Jan 2017
Experiences from industry: Health and Safety effects and challenges on older people
Thomas, D. 2017. Experiences from industry: Health and Safety effects and challenges on older people. The Ageing Workforce: Implications for the Occupational Safety and Health Professions. Queen Anne, University of Greenwich 19 Feb 2017
Fire safety in construction management
Thomas, D. 2017. Fire safety in construction management. APSE Housing, Construction & Building Maintenance Advisory Group - (Southern region). London Borough of Tower Hamlets 19 Oct 2017
Relationships between waste collection systems and MSD’s
Thomas, D. 2016. Relationships between waste collection systems and MSD’s. IOSH West of Scotland Joint Meeting. Hampden Park , Glasgow 28 Jan 2016
Using body mapping as part of the risk assessment process - a case study
Thomas, D., Hare, B. and Cameron, I. 2018. Using body mapping as part of the risk assessment process - a case study. Policy and Practice in Health and Safety. 16 (2), pp. 224-240. https://doi.org/10.1080/14773996.2018.1491146
The need for closer OSH and HR collaboration
Thomas, D. 2017. The need for closer OSH and HR collaboration. IOSH Magazine.
Care of our people - manual handling of recyclables and waste? Should we be concerned?
Thomas, D. 2010. Care of our people - manual handling of recyclables and waste? Should we be concerned? Zero Waste Conference - Scottish Waste & Resources Conference. Glasgow, UK 06 Oct 2010