Songwriters vs. the recording industry: the use and abuse of statistics in UK streaming debates

Article


Osborne, R. 2023. Songwriters vs. the recording industry: the use and abuse of statistics in UK streaming debates. Popular Music. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0261143023000508
TypeArticle
TitleSongwriters vs. the recording industry: the use and abuse of statistics in UK streaming debates
AuthorsOsborne, R.
Abstract

In Britain, the Select Committee of the government department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport has investigated the economics of streaming and recommended that the share of revenues for record companies should decrease so that songwriters can earn more. This article addresses lobbying activity that has resulted from this recommendation. To support their causes, songwriter representatives and record company organisations have made incorrect or misleading use of data from the report Music Creators’ Earnings in the Digital Age. This article looks at the impact of these uses and provides corrections and alternatives to the statistics that have been employed. It also looks at the importance of the issues that have been raised. In conclusion, it addresses aspects of record company accounting that will need to be considered if an increase for songwriters is to be made at their expense.

KeywordsStreaming; Lobbying; Songwriters; Record Companies; Statistics
Sustainable Development Goals8 Decent work and economic growth
Middlesex University ThemeCreativity, Culture & Enterprise
Research GroupMusic group
PublisherCambridge University Press
JournalPopular Music
ISSN0261-1430
Electronic1474-0095
Publication dates
Print15 Dec 2023
Publication process dates
Accepted27 Oct 2023
Deposited14 Feb 2024
Output statusPublished
Publisher's version
License
File Access Level
Open
Copyright Statement

Popular Music (2023). © The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press. This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/),
which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution and reproduction, provided the original article is properly cited.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1017/S0261143023000508
Web of Science identifierWOS:001125078300001
LanguageEnglish
Permalink -

https://repository.mdx.ac.uk/item/yv673

  • 53
    total views
  • 12
    total downloads
  • 1
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

UK music before and after Covid-19
Osborne, R. 2023. UK music before and after Covid-19. International Journal of Cultural Policy. https://doi.org/10.1080/10286632.2023.2214151
Copyright, royalties and industrial decline
Osborne, R. 2021. Copyright, royalties and industrial decline. in: Harrison, A. and Rigg, T. (ed.) The Present and Future of Music Law Bloomsbury Academic. pp. 27-45
Rights reversion and contract adjustment
Osborne, R. and Sun, H. 2023. Rights reversion and contract adjustment. Intellectual Property Office.
Owning the masters: a history of sound recording copyright
Osborne, R. 2022. Owning the masters: a history of sound recording copyright. New York, London and Dublin Bloomsbury Academic.
Music creators' earnings in the digital era
Osborne, R., Hesmondhalgh, D., Sun, H. and Barr, K. 2021. Music creators' earnings in the digital era. Intellectual Property Office.
Introduction
Osborne, R. 2021. Introduction. in: Osborne, R. and Laing, D. (ed.) Music by numbers: the use and abuse of statistics in the music industries Bristol, UK Intellect. pp. 1-17
Live music vs. recorded music
Osborne, R. 2021. Live music vs. recorded music. in: Osborne, R. and Laing, D. (ed.) Music by numbers: the use and abuse of statistics in the music industries Bristol Intellect. pp. 127-147
'I am a one in ten': success ratios in the recording industry
Osborne, R. 2021. 'I am a one in ten': success ratios in the recording industry. in: Osborne, R. and Laing, D. (ed.) Music by Numbers: The Use and Abuse of Statistics in the Music Industries Bristol, UK Intellect. pp. 56-71
The gold disc: one million pop fans can’t be wrong
Osborne, R. 2021. The gold disc: one million pop fans can’t be wrong. in: Osborne, R. and Laing, D. (ed.) Music by numbers: the use and abuse of statistics in the music industries Bristol, UK Intellect. pp. 39-55
At the sign of the swingin’ symbol: the manipulation of the UK Singles Chart
Osborne, R. 2021. At the sign of the swingin’ symbol: the manipulation of the UK Singles Chart. in: Osborne, R. and Laing, D. (ed.) Music by numbers: the use and abuse of statistics in the music industries Bristol, UK Intellect. pp. 20-28
Vinyl, Vinyl everywhere: The analog record in the digital world
Osborne, R. 2018. Vinyl, Vinyl everywhere: The analog record in the digital world. in: Wolf, M. (ed.) The Routledge Companion to Media Technology and Obsolescence Routledge. pp. 200-214
Moby, Minstrelsy and Melville
Osborne, R. 2018. Moby, Minstrelsy and Melville. in: Beaven, Z., O'Dair, M. and Osborne, R. (ed.) Mute Records: Artists, business, history New York and London Bloomsbury Academic. pp. 169-182
Introduction: Mute Records
Osborne, R. and Beaven, Z. 2018. Introduction: Mute Records. in: Beaven, Z., O'Dair, M. and Osborne, R. (ed.) Mute Records: Artists, business, history New York and London Bloomsbury Academic. pp. 1-14
Six types of silence
Osborne, R. 2018. Six types of silence. in: Bennett, S. and Bates, E. (ed.) Critical Approaches to the Production of Music and Sound New York Bloomsbury Academic. pp. 211-228
Success ratios, new music and sound recording copyright
Osborne, R. 2017. Success ratios, new music and sound recording copyright. Popular Music. 36 (3), pp. 393-409. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0261143017000319
Is equitable remuneration equitable? Performers' rights in the UK
Osborne, R. 2017. Is equitable remuneration equitable? Performers' rights in the UK. Popular Music and Society. 40 (5), pp. 573-591. https://doi.org/10.1080/03007766.2017.1348660
'That's me in the spotlight': audiences and musicians on screen
Osborne, R. 2016. 'That's me in the spotlight': audiences and musicians on screen. in: Tsioulakis, I. and Hytönen-Ng, E. (ed.) Musicians and their Audiences: Performance, Speech and Mediation Abingdon Routledge. pp. 134-150
Music on the blockchain
O'Dair, M., Beaven, Z., Neilson, D., Osborne, R. and Pacifico, P. 2016. Music on the blockchain. Middlesex University.
A great friggin' swindle? Sex Pistols, school kids and 1979
Osborne, R. 2015. A great friggin' swindle? Sex Pistols, school kids and 1979. Popular Music and Society. 38 (4), pp. 432-449. https://doi.org/10.1080/03007766.2015.1034496
The gold disc: one million pop fans can't be wrong?
Osborne, R. 2014. The gold disc: one million pop fans can't be wrong? in: Sarafian, V. and Findlay, R. (ed.) L’état de l’industrie musicale = The state of the music industry Toulouse Presses de l'Université Toulouse 1 Capitole.
Audio books: the literary origins of grooves, labels and sleeves
Osborne, R. 2014. Audio books: the literary origins of grooves, labels and sleeves. in: Carroll, R. and Hansen, A. (ed.) LitPop: Writing and Popular Music Farnham Ashgate. pp. 201-215
Vinyl: a history of the analogue record
Osborne, R. 2012. Vinyl: a history of the analogue record. Farnham Ashgate.
I curse your preoccupation with your record collection: The Fall on vinyl 1978-83
Osborne, R. 2010. I curse your preoccupation with your record collection: The Fall on vinyl 1978-83. in: Goddard, M. and Halligan, B. (ed.) Mark E. Smith and The Fall: art, music and politics Farnham, UK Ashgate. pp. 67-75
India on film, 1939-1947
Osborne, R. 2011. India on film, 1939-1947. in: Grieveson, L. and MacCabe, C. (ed.) Film and the end of empire London Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 118-149
Colonial film: moving images of the British Empire
Osborne, R. 2011. Colonial film: moving images of the British Empire. [Author].