Criticality in the mediation of fashion

Conference paper


Dick, E., Gobin, K. and Thomas, P. 2015. Criticality in the mediation of fashion. Textual Fashion. University of Brighton, Brighton, United Kingdom 08 - 10 Jul 2015
TypeConference paper
TitleCriticality in the mediation of fashion
AuthorsDick, E., Gobin, K. and Thomas, P.
Abstract

Criticality in the Mediation of Fashion is a panel for discussion of the role of criticality in the mediation of fashion.
There appears to be a significant mis-match in the value of criticality in the contexts of the art school and the fashion industry. In the former, it plays a key role, and is often an aspect that students find highly challenging; in the latter, in the blogosphere in particular, it seems not to be very highly valued at all. This panel will consider why this seems to be the case, and will ask whether criticality has a place in the mediation of fashion anymore, drawing on examples from education, academia and the fashion industry.
The panel will consider:
- what “criticality” is understood to be/mean;
- what value/relevance “criticality” is perceived to have in the art school and in the fashion industry;
- how “criticality” is, or is not present or practised in the mediation of fashion, in the two contexts;
- how “criticality” can be expressed variously through image, text and garment;
- why this is the case.
Criticality in the Mediation of Fashion will combine two presentations with audience-led discussion. The presentations will focus on:
1. Contexts for criticality in fashion-writing;
2. Criticality in industry writing.
Our analysis will draw on literature considering the dual roles of fashion-writing as both critical and promotional and will apply this, as established stakeholders in both art school and industry, to reflections on the personal practice and rich interdisciplinary experience of members of the What’s that...? collective.
Paper 1: Critical approaches to mediating ‘ethical’ fashion
This paper provides a broad overview of the history and culture of the contexts for “criticality” in fashion writing, looking at examples of fashion journalism and charts the evolution of critical thinking and its introduction to academic studies of fashion in the 20th and 21st century curriculum of the British art school.
Taking ‘Ethical’ fashion as a key focus for the presentation, the paper will compare and contrast the ways in which the concepts of ethics and sustainability in fashion are mediated pedagogically through the academic text and how similar ideas are promoted commercially through industry-focused materials. This will be done through an analysis of the discourse of these texts.
The presentation looks at the ways in which image and text work together to perform contemporary critical debates on the ethics and sustainability agenda within fashion education and the fashion industry and opens up spaces for further discussions about the role of textual fashion within a world of goods and images.
Paper 2 Trend makers and taste makers
Has the era of the blogger surpassed that of the critic? With the traditional mediation of fashion being recorded and accounted through review and critique, these days through social media we have an almost instant account - visual and textual - of a collection or body of work. However, the judgment and authority of this account is variable.
Some bloggers have become extremely influential as taste makers in their own right and their perceived authority has begun to surpass that of expert fashion journalists working in traditional media. Armed with just a smart phone, these amateurs, or professional consumers, have become institutionalised as authorities on mediating catwalk fashion and some of them now run global empires of taste, securing substantial income from advertising, often without expressing any critical comment. Hashtags and a limit of 144 characters dictate the level to which an opinion can be built. These #fashioncommentators are reliant on their privileged access to the front row, and thus negative comment or critical thinking can limit their access to the shows.
This paper discusses examples of commentary from well-known bloggers and writers and explores how more traditional ideas about criticality and review co exists with more contemporary pithy soundbites, exponentially disseminated through cross-posting.

KeywordsFashion, Criticality, Mediation, Writing, Blogging, Reviewer, Ethical Fashion, Canon
Research GroupFashion and Interiors
LanguageEnglish
ConferenceTextual Fashion
Publication dates
Print08 Jul 2015
Publication process dates
Deposited21 Jul 2015
Output statusPublished
Copyright Statement

Access to full text restricted pending copyright check.

Permalink -

https://repository.mdx.ac.uk/item/85v2v

Restricted files

Publisher's version

  • 27
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 0
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Humans of interiors – diversity by design
Murialdo, F., Thomas, P., Elvin, R. and McKenzie, K. 2022. Humans of interiors – diversity by design. Adil, Z. (ed.) A Focus on Pedagogy: Teaching, Learning and Research in the Modern Academy. Virtual 20 - 22 Apr 2022 Architecture Media Politics Society. pp. 173-184
Reflections on textile and memory. The invisible hand and women's work: Dean Castle Textile Team at the Dick Institute, Kilmarnock
Dick, E. and Mullaniff, K. 2020. Reflections on textile and memory. The invisible hand and women's work: Dean Castle Textile Team at the Dick Institute, Kilmarnock. in: Deepwell, K. (ed.) Feminist Art Activisms and Artivisms Amsterdam, The Netherlands Valiz.
'Textile and memory' at the Dick Institute Scotland
Mullaniff, K. and Dick, E. 2019. 'Textile and memory' at the Dick Institute Scotland. East Ayrshire Leisure, Dick Institute, Elmbank Avenue Kilmarnock KA1 3BU 01 2019 - 31 Dec 2020
Documenting through drawing during a field trip to Maurituis working with the Science and Technology Department in conjunction with Lee Durrell
Ursell, M., Eveleigh, A. and Thomas, P. 2017. Documenting through drawing during a field trip to Maurituis working with the Science and Technology Department in conjunction with Lee Durrell.
Mauritius drawing exhibition
Eveleigh, A., Ursell, M. and Thomas, P. 2017. Mauritius drawing exhibition. Middlesex University, Grove building 02 Jun 2017
Images resulting from a drawing and painting trip to Mauritius
Eveleigh, A., Ursell, M. and Thomas, P. 2017. Images resulting from a drawing and painting trip to Mauritius.
Cultural heritage as economic value and social opportunity: SPINNA Circle
Dick, E. and Ganguli, R. 2017. Cultural heritage as economic value and social opportunity: SPINNA Circle. 1st InHerit International Conference on the Value of Cultural Heritage in Athens. Athens, Greece 12 - 13 May 2016 Technical University of Crete. pp. 264-272
Constructing fashionable dress and identity in Bhutan
Dick, E. 2016. Constructing fashionable dress and identity in Bhutan. in: Craik, J. and Jansen, M. (ed.) Modern Fashion Traditions: Negotiating Tradition and Modernity Through Fashion London Bloomsbury Academic. pp. 185-206
From writing spaces to a writing home: encouraging belonging through spatial design
Murialdo, F., Bonazza, R. and Thomas, P. 2019. From writing spaces to a writing home: encouraging belonging through spatial design. in: Scullica, F. and Elgani, E. (ed.) Living, Working and Travelling: New Processes of Hybridization for the Spaces of Hospitality and Work Milano, Italy Franco Angeli srl. pp. 178-186
Performing Eurasia in the textiles and clothing businesses along the Silk Road
Dick, E. 2018. Performing Eurasia in the textiles and clothing businesses along the Silk Road. Cambridge Journal of Eurasian Studies. 2, pp. 1-14. https://doi.org/10.22261/cjes.5n9400
Feminist Art Activisms and Artivisms - 2 July 2018, Middlesex University
Deepwell, K., Kokoli, A., Robinson, A., Mullaniff, K., Dick, E., Attwood, F., Leeson, L. and Maude-Roxby, A. 2018. Feminist Art Activisms and Artivisms - 2 July 2018, Middlesex University. Feminist Art Activisms and Artivisms. Middlesex University, London, UK 02 Jul 2018 Middlesex University. https://doi.org/10.22023/mdx.6716054.v1
The poster session as fusing theory and practice in art and design education: exhibiting an occluded genre
Thomas, P. and Lees-Maffei, G. 2018. The poster session as fusing theory and practice in art and design education: exhibiting an occluded genre. Journal of Writing in Creative Practice. 11 (2), pp. 233-259. https://doi.org/10.1386/jwcp.11.2.233_1
Leadership for sustainability: leading for equality and the future in teaching
Dick, E. and O'Loughlin, M. 2014. Leadership for sustainability: leading for equality and the future in teaching. CREATE/Feminisms Conference 2014. Middlesex University London 22 Jul 2014
DRAFT Three
Murialdo, F., Fern, D., House, N., Bodnar, K., Bonazza, R., Evans, G., Jensen, S., King, S., Morris, L., Mundia, P., Thomas, P., Yeung, W., Church, C. and Vidal Gomez, P. 2017. DRAFT Three. London, UK Middlesex University.
'I am a magazine'
Hendon, Z. and Thomas, P. 2017. 'I am a magazine'. Beyond the Lecture Theatre: Scottish Universities Special Collections and Archives Group. University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen 26 - 27 Jan 2017
Writing spaces
Murialdo, F., Thomas, P. and Bonazza, R. 2017. Writing spaces. EATAW (European Association for the Teaching of Academic Writing) 2017. Royal Holloway, University of London in the United Kingdom 19 - 21 Jun 2017
Draft two
Murialdo, F., Fern, D., House, N., Mortimer, J., Koslowski, B., Thomas, P. and Evans, G. 2016. Draft two. InteriorsMDX.
'Looking away': private writing techniques as a form of transformational text shaping in art & design and the natural sciences
Thomas, P. and Armstrong, T. 2016. 'Looking away': private writing techniques as a form of transformational text shaping in art & design and the natural sciences. Journal of Academic Writing. 6 (1), pp. 59-72. https://doi.org/10.18552/joaw.v6i1.289
Lost luggage
Fernandes, G., Parker, O. and Thomas, P. 2016. Lost luggage. GLAD conference 2016: Creative Pedagogies Across Disciplines. Birmingham, United Kingdom 26 Feb 2016
EAP essentials: a teacher’s guide to principles and practice [Book review]
Thomas, P. 2012. EAP essentials: a teacher’s guide to principles and practice [Book review]. Journal of English for Academic Purposes. 11 (3), pp. 277-279. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jeap.2011.08.002
A framework for usable pedagogy: case studies towards accessibility, criticality and visibility
Gimenez, J. and Thomas, P. 2016. A framework for usable pedagogy: case studies towards accessibility, criticality and visibility. in: Lillis, T., Harrington, K., Lea, M. and Mitchell, S. (ed.) Working with Academic Literacies: Case studies towards transformative practice Anderson, South Carolina Parlour Press. pp. 29-44
'Garland' at MYB Textiles
Mullaniff, K. and Dick, E. 2015. 'Garland' at MYB Textiles. MYB Textiles 04 Jun - 31 Jul 2015
Collaboration & dialogue in embedded academic writing and language interventions, or how Ac Lits changed my (academic) life
Thomas, P. 2015. Collaboration & dialogue in embedded academic writing and language interventions, or how Ac Lits changed my (academic) life. 8th Biennial EATAW conference 2015 (European Association for the Teaching of Academic Writing). Tallinn University of Technology, Tallinn, Estonia. 15 - 17 Jun 2015
“Looking away”: private writing techniques as transformational text shaping
Thomas, P. and Armstrong, T. 2015. “Looking away”: private writing techniques as transformational text shaping. 8th Biennial EATAW conference 2015 (European Association for the Teaching of Academic Writing). Tallinn University of Technology, Tallinn, Estonia. 15 - 17 Jun 2015
Questions of agency and the artisan within Uzbekistan
Dick, E. 2014. Questions of agency and the artisan within Uzbekistan. 3rd International (Non)Western Fashion Conference The Global Politics of Fashion. University of Hong Kong 22 - 23 Nov 2014
Transformation, dialogue and collaboration: developing studio-based concept writing in Art and Design through embedded interventions
Thomas, P. 2013. Transformation, dialogue and collaboration: developing studio-based concept writing in Art and Design through embedded interventions. Journal of Academic Writing. 3 (1), pp. 42-66. https://doi.org/10.18552/joaw.v3i1.95